Guarducci Giovanni, Porchia Barbara Rita, Lorenzini Carlotta, Nante Nicola
Post Graduate School of Public Health, University of Siena, Siena, Italy.
Hygiene and Epidemiology Unit, Teaching Hospital of Siena, Siena, Italy.
Infez Med. 2023 Mar 1;31(1):13-19. doi: 10.53854/liim-3101-3. eCollection 2022.
In 2022, a new outbreak of the Mpox virus occurred outside of Africa, its usual endemic area. The virus was detected in European, American, Asian, and Oceanian countries where Mpox is uncommon or had not been reported previously and where the spread was rapid. The study aims to compare the case definition and the indications for contact tracing in case of Mpox infection among the World Health Organization (WHO), the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC), and four European Countries.
From August 2022 to November 2022, we conducted research, first on the WHO and ECDC official websites and then on the official websites of the Ministry of Health or National Health Agencies of four European Countries (Italy, France, Spain, and Portugal). All reports found were compared to enlighten the differences in the definition of the case and indications for contact tracing.
The WHO divides the case definition into four categories: suspected, probable, confirmed, and discarded, while the ECDC divides cases into confirmed and probable. The ECDC defines contact as close and others, while the WHO divides it into high, medium, and minimal risk. The four countries analyzed show heterogeneity in both the case definitions and the indications for contact tracing.
Our analysis revealed heterogeneity in the case definition between the WHO and ECDC. Different countries followed different indications or have given their indications for both the case definition and contact tracing indications. Harmonization strengthens public health preparedness and response and creates unified communication.
2022年,猴痘病毒在其通常的流行地区非洲以外出现了新的疫情。在欧洲、美洲、亚洲和大洋洲国家检测到了该病毒,这些国家猴痘并不常见或此前未报告过,且病毒传播迅速。本研究旨在比较世界卫生组织(WHO)、欧洲疾病预防控制中心(ECDC)以及四个欧洲国家在猴痘感染病例定义和接触者追踪指征方面的差异。
2022年8月至2022年11月,我们首先在WHO和ECDC的官方网站上进行研究,然后在四个欧洲国家(意大利、法国、西班牙和葡萄牙)的卫生部或国家卫生机构的官方网站上进行研究。对所有找到的报告进行比较,以揭示病例定义和接触者追踪指征方面的差异。
WHO将病例定义分为四类:疑似、可能、确诊和排除,而ECDC将病例分为确诊和可能。ECDC将接触者定义为密切接触者和其他接触者,而WHO将其分为高、中、低风险。所分析的四个国家在病例定义和接触者追踪指征方面均表现出异质性。
我们的分析揭示了WHO和ECDC在病例定义方面的异质性。不同国家在病例定义和接触者追踪指征方面遵循不同的指征或给出了自己的指征。协调一致可加强公共卫生防范和应对,并实现统一的沟通。