Fadelalla Mohammed Gadoora, Elbakri Sabreen, Poon Michael
Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Edinburgh Royal Infirmary, Edinburgh, UK.
Department of General Surgery, Ninewells Hospital, Dundee, UK.
Scott Med J. 2023 May;68(2):58-62. doi: 10.1177/00369330231163375. Epub 2023 Mar 13.
Intraoperative feedback can be associated with improved surgical performance. Quality feedback can reduce the time required by trainees to achieve proficiency in psychomotor skills. Operative training time has become increasingly limited, and it has become imperative to use surgical training time effectively.
In this survey, we assessed trainees' perspectives of intraoperative feedback. We included several aspects of feedback including its occurrence, quality, and potential barriers.
All surgical trainees in a single centre were invited to complete an electronic questionnaire. Participants were anonymised. We summarised data using descriptive statistics.
Most trainees (85%) reported they had the opportunity to share their training goals with trainers. Just under three-quarters of trainees felt they always or sometimes got timely feedback. Only half of the trainees were signposted to feedback and 23% felt feedback was not part of their department's culture. Half of the trainees did not always feel comfortable asking for feedback from their trainers stating their reasons as fear of criticism, lack of time and competing clinical commitments.
There is no denying the importance of feedback on operative performance, however, this survey shows that many of the pillars of quality feedback are poorly adhered to.
术中反馈可与手术表现的提升相关联。高质量的反馈可以减少学员达到心理运动技能熟练程度所需的时间。手术培训时间变得越来越紧张,因此必须有效地利用手术培训时间。
在这项调查中,我们评估了学员对术中反馈的看法。我们纳入了反馈的几个方面,包括其发生、质量和潜在障碍。
我们邀请了一个中心的所有外科学员完成一份电子问卷。参与者是匿名的。我们使用描述性统计数据对数据进行总结。
大多数学员(85%)报告他们有机会与培训师分享他们的培训目标。近四分之三的学员感到他们总是或有时能得到及时的反馈。只有一半的学员被引导获得反馈,23%的学员认为反馈不是他们部门文化的一部分。一半的学员并不总是感到舒适向培训师寻求反馈,他们的理由是害怕批评、缺乏时间和临床工作冲突。
毋庸置疑,手术表现的反馈很重要,然而,这项调查表明,高质量反馈的许多支柱都没有得到很好的遵循。