Guo P, Tao L, Wang C, Lyu H R, Yang Y, Hu H, Li G X, Liu F, Li Y X, Ye Y J, Wang S
Department of Emergency General Surgery, Peking University People's Hospital, Beijing 100044, China.
Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Anshun People's Hospital, Anshun 561000, China.
Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2023 Mar 25;26(3):277-282. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn441530-20230215-00037.
To propose a new staging system for presacral recurrence of rectal cancer and explore the factors influencing radical resection of such recurrences based on this staging system. In this retrospective observational study, clinical data of 51 patients with presacral recurrence of rectal cancer who had undergone surgical treatment in the Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Peking University People's Hospital between January 2008 and September 2022 were collected. Inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) primary rectal cancer without distant metastasis that had been radically resected; (2) pre-sacral recurrence of rectal cancer confirmed by multi-disciplinary team assessment based on CT, MRI, positron emission tomography, physical examination, surgical exploration, and pathological examination of biopsy tissue in some cases; and (3) complete inpatient, outpatient and follow-up data. The patients were allocated to radical resection and non-radical resection groups according to postoperative pathological findings. The study included: (1) classification of pre-sacral recurrence of rectal cancer according to its anatomical characteristics as follows: Type I: no involvement of the sacrum; Type II: involvement of the low sacrum, but no other sites; Type III: involvement of the high sacrum, but no other sites; and Type IV: involvement of the sacrum and other sites. (2) Assessment of postoperative presacral recurrence, overall survival from surgery to recurrence, and duration of disease-free survival. (3) Analysis of factors affecting radical resection of pre-sacral recurrence of rectal cancer. Non-normally distributed measures are expressed as median (range). The Mann-Whitney test was used for comparison between groups. The median follow-up was 25 (2-96) months with a 100% follow-up rate. The rate of metachronic distant metastasis was significantly lower in the radical resection than in the non-radical resection group (24.1% [7/29] vs. 54.5% [12/22], χ=8.333, =0.026). Postoperative disease-free survival was longer in the radical resection group (32.7 months [3.0-63.0] vs. 16.1 [1.0-41.0], =8.907, =0.005). Overall survival was longer in the radical resection group (39.2 [3.0-66.0] months vs. 28.1 [1.0-52.0] months, =1.042, =0.354). According to univariate analysis, age, sex, distance between the tumor and anal verge, primary tumor pT stage, and primary tumor grading were not associated with achieving R0 resection of presacral recurrences of rectal cancer (all >0.05), whereas primary tumor pN stage, anatomic staging of presacral recurrence, and procedure for managing presacral recurrence were associated with rate of R0 resection (all <0.05). According to multifactorial analysis, the pathological stage of the primary tumor pN1-2 (OR=3.506, 95% CI: 1.089-11.291, =0.035), type of procedure (transabdominal resection: OR=29.250, 95% CI: 2.789 - 306.811, =0.005; combined abdominal perineal resection: OR=26.000, 95% CI: 2.219-304.702, =0.009), and anatomical stage of presacral recurrence (Type III: OR=16.000, 95% CI: 1.542 - 166.305, = 0.020; type IV: OR= 36.667, 95% CI: 3.261 - 412.258, = 0.004) were all independent risk factors for achieving radical resection of anterior sacral recurrence after rectal cancer surgery. Stage of presacral recurrences of rectal cancer is an independent predictor of achieving R0 resection. It is possible to predict whether radical resection can be achieved on the basis of the patient's medical history.
提出一种新的直肠癌骶前复发分期系统,并基于该分期系统探讨影响此类复发根治性切除的因素。在这项回顾性观察研究中,收集了2008年1月至2022年9月期间在北京大学人民医院胃肠外科接受手术治疗的51例直肠癌骶前复发患者的临床资料。纳入标准如下:(1)原发性直肠癌无远处转移且已行根治性切除;(2)经多学科团队基于CT、MRI、正电子发射断层扫描、体格检查、手术探查以及部分病例活检组织病理检查确诊为直肠癌骶前复发;(3)具备完整的住院、门诊及随访资料。根据术后病理结果将患者分为根治性切除组和非根治性切除组。研究内容包括:(1)根据直肠癌骶前复发的解剖学特征进行分类:I型:未累及骶骨;II型:累及低位骶骨,但未累及其他部位;III型:累及高位骶骨,但未累及其他部位;IV型:累及骶骨及其他部位。(2)评估术后骶前复发情况、手术至复发的总生存期以及无病生存期。(3)分析影响直肠癌骶前复发根治性切除的因素。非正态分布的指标以中位数(范围)表示。采用Mann-Whitney检验进行组间比较。中位随访时间为25(2 - 96)个月,随访率为100%。根治性切除组异时性远处转移率显著低于非根治性切除组(24.1% [7/29] 对54.5% [12/22],χ = 8.333, = 0.026)。根治性切除组术后无病生存期更长(32.7个月 [3.0 - 63.0] 对16.1 [1.0 - 41.0], = 8.907, = 0.005)。根治性切除组总生存期更长(39.2 [3.0 - 66.0] 个月对28.1 [1.0 - 52.0] 个月, = 1.042, = 0.354)。单因素分析显示,年龄、性别、肿瘤距肛缘距离、原发肿瘤pT分期及原发肿瘤分级与直肠癌骶前复发实现R0切除无关(均>0.05),而原发肿瘤pN分期、骶前复发的解剖学分期及骶前复发的处理方式与R0切除率相关(均<0.05)。多因素分析显示,原发肿瘤病理分期pN1 - 2(OR = 3.506,95% CI:1.089 - 11.291, = 0.035)、手术方式(经腹切除:OR = 29.250,95% CI:2.789 - 306.811, = 0.005;腹会阴联合切除:OR = 26.000,95% CI:2.219 - 304.702, = 0.009)以及骶前复发的解剖学分期(III型:OR = 16.000,95% CI:1.542 - 166.305, = 0.020;IV型:OR = 36.667,95% CI:3.261 - 412.258, = 0.004)均为直肠癌术后骶前复发实现根治性切除的独立危险因素。直肠癌骶前复发分期是实现R0切除的独立预测因素。根据患者病史有可能预测是否能实现根治性切除。