Department of Human Anatomy and Physiology, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Human Variation and Identification Research Unit, School of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Int J Legal Med. 2023 May;137(3):743-752. doi: 10.1007/s00414-023-02978-3. Epub 2023 Mar 16.
An age-at-death estimation method using the first rib may be particularly advantageous as this rib is relatively easy to identify, not easily damaged postmortem, and associated with less mechanical stresses compared to other age indicators. Previously, mixed results have been achieved using the first rib to estimate age-at-death. This study aimed to develop and test an age-at-death estimation method using the first rib. An identified modern black South African sample of 260 skeletons were used to collect age-related data from the first rib. Multiple linear regression analysis equations were created from this data for male, female, and combined samples. When tested on a hold-out sample, equations generated mean inaccuracies of 7-13 years for point estimates. The 95% confidence intervals contained the true age in 11-33% of individuals depending on the equation used, but wider intervals generated using 95% prediction intervals contained true ages for 100% of individuals. Point estimate inaccuracies are comparable to other age-at-death estimation methods and may be useful if single indicator estimation is unavoidable in the case of missing or damaged bones. However, combined methods that use indicators from many areas of the skeleton are preferable and may reduce interval widths.
一种使用第一肋骨进行年龄推断的方法可能具有优势,因为第一肋骨相对容易识别,死后不易受损,与其他年龄指标相比,受到的机械应力较小。此前,使用第一肋骨进行年龄推断的结果参差不齐。本研究旨在开发和测试一种使用第一肋骨进行年龄推断的方法。利用 260 具现代南非黑人骨骼样本,收集第一肋骨的年龄相关数据。为男性、女性和混合样本创建了来自该数据的多元线性回归分析方程。在留一样本上进行测试时,方程生成的点估计平均误差为 7-13 年。根据使用的方程,95%置信区间在 11-33%的个体中包含真实年龄,但使用 95%预测区间生成的更宽区间包含了 100%个体的真实年龄。点估计误差与其他年龄推断方法相当,如果在骨骼缺失或受损的情况下不可避免地需要进行单一指标估计,则可能会有用。然而,使用骨骼多个区域指标的综合方法更为可取,并且可能会减少区间宽度。