Department of Genetics, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Vanboeijen, Assen, The Netherlands.
Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2023 Mar 19;18(1):60. doi: 10.1186/s13023-023-02657-x.
Even with the introduction of new genetic techniques that enable accurate genomic characterization, knowledge about the phenotypic spectrum of rare chromosomal disorders is still limited, both in literature and existing databases. Yet this clinical information is of utmost importance for health professionals and the parents of children with rare diseases. Since existing databases are often hampered by the limited time and willingness of health professionals to input new data, we collected phenotype data directly from parents of children with a chromosome 6 disorder. These parents were reached via social media, and the information was collected via the online Chromosome 6 Questionnaire, which includes 115 main questions on congenital abnormalities, medical problems, behaviour, growth and development.
Here, we assess data consistency by comparing parent-reported phenotypes to phenotypes based on copies of medical files for the same individual (n = 20) and data availability by comparing the data available on specific characteristics reported by parents (n = 34) to data available in existing literature (n = 39).
The reported answers to the main questions on phenotype characteristics were 85-95% consistent, and the consistency of answers to subsequent more detailed questions was 77-96%. For all but two main questions, significantly more data was collected from parents via the Chromosome 6 Questionnaire than was currently available in literature. For the topics developmental delay and brain abnormalities, no significant difference in the amount of available data was found. The only feature for which significantly more data was available in literature was a sub-question on the type of brain abnormality present.
This is the first study to compare phenotype data collected directly from parents to data extracted from medical files on the same individuals. We found that the data was highly consistent, and phenotype data collected via the online Chromosome 6 Questionnaire resulted in more available information on most clinical characteristics when compared to phenotypes reported in literature reports thus far. We encourage active patient participation in rare disease research and have shown that parent-reported phenotypes are reliable and contribute to our knowledge of the phenotypic spectrum of rare chromosomal disorders.
即使引入了新的基因技术,可以实现准确的基因组特征描述,但关于罕见染色体疾病的表型谱的知识,无论是在文献中还是现有的数据库中,仍然有限。然而,对于健康专业人员和患有罕见疾病的儿童的父母来说,这些临床信息是至关重要的。由于现有数据库通常受到健康专业人员输入新数据的时间和意愿的限制,我们直接从患有 6 号染色体疾病的儿童的父母那里收集表型数据。这些父母是通过社交媒体联系的,信息是通过在线 6 号染色体问卷收集的,该问卷包括 115 个关于先天异常、医疗问题、行为、生长发育的主要问题。
在这里,我们通过比较个体的医疗文件中的表型数据(n=20)和家长报告的表型数据,评估数据的一致性;通过比较家长报告的特定特征的数据可用性(n=34)与现有文献中的数据可用性(n=39),评估数据的可用性。
主要表型特征问题的报告答案的一致性为 85-95%,随后更详细问题的答案一致性为 77-96%。除了两个主要问题外,通过 6 号染色体问卷从父母那里收集的数据明显多于目前文献中的数据。对于发育迟缓和大脑异常这两个主题,可用数据量没有显著差异。唯一在文献中可用数据量更多的特征是存在的大脑异常类型的子问题。
这是第一项将直接从父母那里收集的表型数据与同一人群的医疗文件中提取的数据进行比较的研究。我们发现数据高度一致,与迄今为止文献报道的表型相比,通过在线 6 号染色体问卷收集的表型数据在大多数临床特征上产生了更多的可用信息。我们鼓励患者积极参与罕见病研究,并表明家长报告的表型是可靠的,并有助于我们了解罕见染色体疾病的表型谱。