Wright Elizabeth C, Kapuria Devika, Ben-Yakov Gil, Sharma Disha, Basu Dev, Cho Min Ho, Abijo Tomilowo, Wilkins Kenneth J
Office of the Director, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.
Department of Gastroenterology, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, MO.
Gastro Hep Adv. 2023 Mar;2(3):370-379. doi: 10.1016/j.gastha.2022.12.003. Epub 2022 Dec 16.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Results of randomized clinical trials are often first presented as conference abstracts, but these abstracts may be difficult to find, and trial results included in the abstract may not be followed by subsequent journal publications. In a review of abstracts submitted to eight major medical and surgical conferences in 2017, we identified 237 abstracts reporting primary results of randomized clinical trials accepted for presentation at three major gastroenterology and hepatology conferences. The aims of this new analysis were to determine the publication rate for these abstracts and the proportion of publications that included trial registration numbers in the publication abstract.
Clinical trial registries, PubMed, Europe PMC, and Google Scholar were searched through November 1, 2021, for publications reporting trial results for the selected abstracts. Publications were reviewed to determine if they included a trial registration number and if the registration number was in the abstract.
Publications were found for 157 abstracts (66%) within four years of the conference. Publications were found more frequently for the 194 abstracts reporting results of registered trials (144, 74%) than for the 43 abstracts reporting unregistered trials (13, 30%), but only 67% of these 144 publications included the registration number in the publication abstract. Ten unpublished trials had summary results posted on ClinicalTrials.gov.
Clinical trial results could be more accessible if all trials were registered, authors included registration numbers in both conference and journal abstracts, and journal editors required the inclusion of registration numbers in publication abstracts for registered clinical trials.
随机临床试验的结果通常首先以会议摘要的形式呈现,但这些摘要可能难以查找,且摘要中包含的试验结果可能不会有后续的期刊发表跟进。在对2017年提交给八大主要医学和外科会议的摘要进行的一项综述中,我们识别出237篇报告随机临床试验主要结果的摘要,这些摘要已被接受在三大主要胃肠病学和肝病学会议上展示。这项新分析的目的是确定这些摘要的发表率以及发表摘要中包含试验注册号的发表比例。
检索临床试验注册库、PubMed、欧洲PMC和谷歌学术,直至2021年11月1日,查找报告所选摘要试验结果的出版物。对出版物进行审查,以确定它们是否包含试验注册号以及注册号是否在摘要中。
在会议后的四年内,找到了157篇摘要(66%)的出版物。报告已注册试验结果的194篇摘要(144篇,74%)比报告未注册试验的43篇摘要(13篇,30%)更频繁地找到出版物,但这144篇出版物中只有67%在发表摘要中包含注册号。有10项未发表的试验在ClinicalTrials.gov上公布了总结结果。
如果所有试验都进行注册,作者在会议和期刊摘要中都包含注册号,并且期刊编辑要求在已注册临床试验的发表摘要中包含注册号,那么临床试验结果可能会更容易获取。