Deane Kevin, Wamoyi Joyce, Mgunga Samwel, Changalucha John
Economics Department, Open University, Milton Keynes, United Kingdom.
Sexual and Reproductive Health Department, National Institute for Medical Research, Mwanza Research Centre, Mwanza, Tanzania.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2022 Nov 21;2(11):e0000058. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0000058. eCollection 2022.
Workplaces have been increasingly promoted as key sites for HIV interventions, with cost-benefit analyses employed to demonstrate the financial benefits to employers for implementing workplace HIV programmes. In these analyses, the potential costs of having HIV positive employees are weighed against the costs of the workplace programmes. Despite evidence that shows some firms have saved significant sums of money through these interventions, the general response from the private sector has been limited, with most positive case studies originating from high prevalence settings. This article reports findings from qualitative fieldwork conducted in Tanzania with private and public sector employers that aimed to understand how HIV was addressed in their organisations. Our findings suggest that HIV is not generally a serious issue, and hence HIV interventions are primarily ad-hoc with few formal HIV workplace programmes. We also found that in cases where compulsory testing programmes were implemented, employees did not turn up for testing and thus lost access to employment. Our findings suggest that relying on workplace programmes in lower prevalence settings is no substitute for investment in public health systems. Employer interventions should emphasise education and awareness, condom distribution and the promotion and provision of self-testing kits.
工作场所越来越多地被视为艾滋病毒干预的关键场所,成本效益分析被用来向雇主证明实施工作场所艾滋病毒项目的经济效益。在这些分析中,将雇佣艾滋病毒呈阳性员工的潜在成本与工作场所项目的成本进行权衡。尽管有证据表明一些公司通过这些干预节省了大量资金,但私营部门的总体反应有限,大多数积极的案例研究都来自高流行率地区。本文报告了在坦桑尼亚对私营和公共部门雇主进行定性实地调查的结果,旨在了解他们的组织中如何应对艾滋病毒问题。我们的研究结果表明,艾滋病毒一般不是一个严重问题,因此艾滋病毒干预主要是临时措施,很少有正式的工作场所艾滋病毒项目。我们还发现,在实施强制检测项目的情况下,员工没有前来检测,从而失去了就业机会。我们的研究结果表明,在低流行率地区依赖工作场所项目无法替代对公共卫生系统的投资。雇主的干预措施应强调教育和提高认识、分发避孕套以及推广和提供自我检测试剂盒。