Thomas Owen, Aruparayil Noel, Gnanaraj Jesudian, Mathew George, Nagarajan Kavikumar, Shinkins Beth, Jayne David
Leeds Institute of Medical Research at St. James's, University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom.
Association of Rural Surgeons of India, Chepauk, India.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023 Jan 6;3(1):e0001233. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0001233. eCollection 2023.
Evidence has shown a trend towards rising mortality from surgical abdominal conditions with increasing distance from hospitals in Eastern India. It has been claimed that imaging modalities such as portable ultrasound are ideal for use in rural areas of developing countries for diagnosis and management of a variety of acute abdominal conditions. This mixed-methods study aimed to explore the need for increased access to POCUS in rural, hard-to-reach populations within India, and to identify barriers that may exist to increasing this access.
This mixed-methods study utilized a health needs assessment framework. Quantitative data was extracted from medical records within two outreach camp organisations supporting hard-to-reach populations in Uttarakhand and Jharkhand to provide contextual background statistics. Qualitative data was collected using semi-structured interviews taken from employees of each outreach camp. A framework analysis was employed to analyse the qualitative data. Both datasets were analysed in parallel.
Twelve semi-structured interviews were undertaken, and 3 months of medical records were reviewed. Themes that presented themselves from the data included the use of camps for case-finding of conditions amenable to routine surgery, a need for POCUS to help with this diagnostic process, a perceived high disease burden from renal calculi, and complex cultural and legislative barriers to POCUS specific to this setting.
POCUS was considered a useful tool in expanding access to surgery for these settings and finding ways of overcoming cultural and legislative barriers to its use should be of high priority. POCUS should be highly portable, robust, easily repairable, and battery operated. For telemedicine to be fully utilised, signal quality will have to be proven to be reliable.
有证据表明,在印度东部,随着与医院距离的增加,腹部外科疾病导致的死亡率呈上升趋势。有人声称,便携式超声等成像方式非常适合在发展中国家农村地区用于诊断和管理各种急性腹部疾病。这项混合方法研究旨在探讨在印度农村难以到达的人群中增加现场即时超声(POCUS)使用机会的必要性,并确定增加这种机会可能存在的障碍。
这项混合方法研究采用了健康需求评估框架。定量数据从两个外展营地组织的医疗记录中提取,这两个组织为北阿坎德邦和恰尔肯德邦难以到达的人群提供服务,以提供背景统计数据。定性数据通过对每个外展营地员工进行半结构化访谈收集。采用框架分析法分析定性数据。两个数据集并行分析。
进行了12次半结构化访谈,并审查了3个月的医疗记录。从数据中呈现出的主题包括利用营地查找适合常规手术的疾病病例、需要POCUS来辅助这一诊断过程、肾结石导致的疾病负担较高,以及针对该环境下POCUS使用的复杂文化和立法障碍。
POCUS被认为是扩大这些地区手术可及性的有用工具,找到克服其使用的文化和立法障碍的方法应成为高度优先事项。POCUS应具有高度便携性、坚固耐用、易于维修且由电池供电。为了充分利用远程医疗,必须证明信号质量可靠。