Kreisberg A Nicole, Hsin Amy
Brown University.
Queens College, CUNY.
J Ethn Migr Stud. 2021;47(17):3822-3845. doi: 10.1080/1369183X.2020.1750947. Epub 2020 May 7.
Despite growth in the number of Latino students enrolled in U.S. colleges, foreign-born Latinos are less likely than both native-born Latinos and other immigrant groups to graduate. However, it is difficult to understand the lower educational attainment of Latino immigrants without considering variation in enrollment by legal status. After all, until recently, undocumented immigrants have been blocked from higher education in the United States. Drawing upon the education and immigrant illegality literature, as well as longitudinal administrative data on 35,400 college students, we examine the association between students' legal status and their educational achievement, or GPA-an important predictor of educational attainment. We find that, despite high achievement in high school and upon first enrolling in college, undocumented students do not experience upward achievement over time, otherwise known in the education literature as educational progression. Rather, their growth is flat, and their level of achievement declines slightly, what we call an educational regression, relative to their documented and foreign-born citizen Latino peers. We identify several individual- and structural-level factors that help explain the pattern and timing of undocumented student regression. The results have implications for studies of immigrant inequality, incorporation, and immigration law in the U.S. and globally.
尽管在美国大学就读的拉丁裔学生数量有所增加,但与本土出生的拉丁裔和其他移民群体相比,外国出生的拉丁裔毕业的可能性较小。然而,如果不考虑按法律身份划分的入学差异,就很难理解拉丁裔移民较低的教育成就。毕竟,直到最近,无证移民在美国仍被高等教育拒之门外。借鉴教育和移民非法性方面的文献,以及35400名大学生的纵向行政数据,我们研究了学生的法律身份与其教育成就(即平均绩点,这是教育成就的一个重要预测指标)之间的关联。我们发现,尽管无证学生在高中时成绩优异,刚进入大学时也表现出色,但随着时间的推移,他们的成绩并没有上升,在教育文献中这被称为教育进步。相反,他们的成绩增长平缓,相对于有证件的外国出生的拉丁裔公民同龄人,他们的成绩水平略有下降,我们称之为教育倒退。我们确定了几个个人层面和结构层面的因素,这些因素有助于解释无证学生倒退的模式和时间。研究结果对美国和全球的移民不平等、融入以及移民法研究具有启示意义。