Raisin Joshua A, Keels Martha Ann, Roberts Michael W, Divaris Kimon, Jain Nina, Adkins Deanna W
J Am Dent Assoc. 2023 May;154(5):384-392.e4. doi: 10.1016/j.adaj.2023.02.009. Epub 2023 Mar 25.
Despite health disparities and barriers to medical care being well documented in the literature, transgender and gender nonbinary (TGNB) people's experiences and expectations with regard to oral health care remain understudied. The authors examined gender identity-related factors influencing experiences in the dental setting, aspects of subjective oral health, and avoidance of oral health care.
One-hundred eighteen TGNB people aged 13 through 70 years completed a 32-item questionnaire designed for this study. Data analysis relied on descriptive methods and bivariate comparisons using a conventional P < .05 statistical significance criterion. Qualitative description analysis was used to identify emerging themes from responses to an open-ended question.
One-third of participants reported misgendering (that is, had been addressed by their incorrect name and pronouns in the dental setting). Although refusal of oral health care was rare in this sample of TGNB participants, more than one-half felt that their usual source of oral health care was not equipped to provide gender-appropriate care. Participants' avoidance due to gender identity was significantly associated with measures of self-reported suboptimal oral health. Common themes related to participants' oral health care experiences included gender insensitivity, awkward interactions, avoidance of care, and lack of gender-affirming providers.
Discrepancies between TGNB patients' expectations and actual experiences suggest that their needs are often unmet in the dental setting, possibly contributing to gender identity-associated dental avoidance and oral health disparities.
Although these results need to be verified in larger and more diverse samples, they provide actionable information for improvement to this population's oral health and management.
尽管文献中充分记录了健康差异和医疗保健障碍,但跨性别者和性别非二元认同者(TGNB)在口腔保健方面的经历和期望仍未得到充分研究。作者研究了影响牙科就诊经历的性别认同相关因素、主观口腔健康方面以及对口腔保健的回避情况。
118名年龄在13至70岁之间的TGNB者完成了为本研究设计的一份包含32个条目的问卷。数据分析依赖于描述性方法和使用传统P<0.05统计学显著性标准的双变量比较。定性描述分析用于从对一个开放式问题的回答中识别新出现的主题。
三分之一的参与者报告遭遇了性别错称(即在牙科就诊时被用错误的名字和代词称呼)。尽管在这个TGNB参与者样本中拒绝口腔保健的情况很少见,但超过一半的人认为他们通常的口腔保健来源没有能力提供适合性别的护理。参与者因性别认同而产生的回避与自我报告的口腔健康欠佳指标显著相关。与参与者口腔保健经历相关的常见主题包括性别不敏感、尴尬互动、回避护理以及缺乏性别肯定性的医疗服务提供者。
TGNB患者的期望与实际经历之间的差异表明,他们的需求在牙科就诊时往往未得到满足,这可能导致与性别认同相关的牙科回避和口腔健康差异。
尽管这些结果需要在更大且更多样化的样本中得到验证,但它们为改善这一人群的口腔健康和管理提供了可采取行动的信息。