Medical Preparedness and Crisis Management Unit (MPCMU), Directorate-General for Personnel, European Parliament, Rue Wiertz, 60, B-1047, Brussels, Belgium.
Operational Research Unit, Doctors with Africa Cuamm, Padova, Italy.
BMC Med Educ. 2023 Mar 27;23(1):184. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04154-y.
Mainstream medical education remains largely focused on national health issues. Therefore, in order to expose medical students to international health issues, it is beneficial to facilitate international medical electives.
This article describes the Junior Project Officer (JPO) program, a medical experience based on clinical electives in Sub-Saharan Africa, supported by a Non-Governmental Organisation (NGO). Residents spend 6 months as part of a multidisciplinary medical team in Africa. A post-elective online survey was administered to all who participated in the program in the period 2002-2020. The questionnaire comprised three domains: (i) general and pre-departure information; (ii) the experience; (iii) the post-experience.
Questionnaires were received from 157/241 subjects, a response rate of 65%. The most common specialties were pediatrics, public health, and internal medicine. Of all, 87% carried out clinical activities; 45% also worked in the management of health services, and 60% carried out research activities. About 64% reported difficulties linked to a lack of equipment, different ways of working (57%), and exposure to situations for which they did not feel technically prepared (56%). In 25% of cases, residents reported that their school's attitude to their doing the elective was not positive: upon their return, over 50% felt that their experience was not sufficiently valued by their institution. Respondents considered the experience important for professional and personal growth (93% and 80% respectively ). Forty-two participants (27%) reported that the experience had a significant impact on their future career choices.
Despite the difficulties encountered, a well-structured experience in international health can have a positive impact on residents, professionally and personally. Key factors behind the positive outcomes are the substantial length (6 months) of the experience, and the long term working relationships between the sending and receiving institutions. The schools in Italy that provide the students for the electives need to see more evidence that international electives are worth the investment.
主流医学教育仍然主要关注国家卫生问题。因此,为了使医学生接触国际卫生问题,促进国际医学实习是有益的。
本文介绍了初级项目官员(JPO)计划,这是一个基于撒哈拉以南非洲临床实习的医学体验,由非政府组织(NGO)支持。住院医师作为多学科医疗团队的一部分在非洲工作 6 个月。对 2002 年至 2020 年期间参加该计划的所有人进行了在线调查。问卷包括三个部分:(一)一般和出发前信息;(二)体验;(三)体验后。
收到了 157/241 名参与者的问卷,回复率为 65%。最常见的专业是儿科、公共卫生和内科。所有人中,87%的人开展了临床活动;45%的人还参与了卫生服务管理工作,60%的人开展了研究活动。约 64%的人报告说,他们遇到了与设备短缺、工作方式不同(57%)和暴露于他们感到技术上准备不足的情况(56%)有关的困难。在 25%的情况下,住院医师报告说,他们学校对他们参加实习的态度不积极:返回后,超过 50%的人认为他们的机构对他们的实习经历重视不够。受访者认为这种体验对专业和个人成长很重要(分别为 93%和 80%)。42 名参与者(27%)报告说,这次经历对他们未来的职业选择有重大影响。
尽管遇到了困难,但结构良好的国际卫生经验对住院医师的专业和个人发展都有积极的影响。积极成果的关键因素是经验的实质性长度(6 个月)以及派遣和接收机构之间的长期工作关系。为实习提供学生的意大利学校需要看到更多证据,证明国际实习是值得投资的。