Centre for Lifestyle Medicine and Behaviour (CLiMB), School of Sport, Exercise and Health Sciences, Loughborough University, Loughborough, Leicestershire, LE11 3TU, UK.
School of Sport, Exercise and Health Sciences, Loughborough University, Loughborough, Leicestershire, LE11 3TU, UK.
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2023 Mar 28;20(1):38. doi: 10.1186/s12966-023-01443-z.
In many Westernised countries, children do not consume a sufficient amount of vegetables for optimal health and development. Child-feeding guidelines have been produced to address this, but often only promote offering vegetables at midday/evening meals and snack times. With guidance having limited success in increasing children's vegetable intake at a population level, novel approaches to address this must be developed. Offering vegetables to children at breakfast time in nursery/kindergarten settings has the potential to increase children's overall daily vegetable consumption as children typically attend nursery/kindergarten and many routinely eat breakfast there. However, the feasibility and acceptability of this intervention (Veggie Brek) to children and nursery staff has not been investigated.
A feasibility and acceptability cluster randomised controlled trial (RCT) was undertaken in eight UK nurseries. All nurseries engaged in one-week baseline and follow-up phases before and after an intervention/control period. Staff in intervention nurseries offered three raw carrot batons and three cucumber sticks alongside children's main breakfast food each day for three weeks. Control nurseries offered children their usual breakfast. Feasibility was assessed by recruitment data and nursery staff's ability to follow the trial protocol. Acceptability was assessed by children's willingness to eat the vegetables at breakfast time. All primary outcomes were assessed against traffic-light progression criteria. Staff preference for collecting data via photographs versus using paper was also assessed. Further views about the intervention were obtained through semi-structured interviews with nursery staff.
The recruitment of parents/caregivers willing to provide consent for eligible children was acceptable at 67.8% (within the amber stop-go criterion) with 351 children taking part across eight nurseries. Both the feasibility and acceptability of the intervention to nursery staff and the willingness of children to consume the vegetables met the green stop-go criteria, with children eating some part of the vegetables in 62.4% (745/1194) of instances where vegetables were offered. Additionally, staff preferred reporting data using paper compared to taking photographs.
Offering vegetables to children at breakfast time in nursery/kindergarten settings is feasible and acceptable to children and nursery staff. A full intervention evaluation should be explored via a definitive RCT.
NCT05217550.
在许多西化国家,儿童的蔬菜摄入量不足,无法达到最佳的健康和发育水平。为此制定了儿童喂养指南,但这些指南通常只提倡在午餐/晚餐和零食时间提供蔬菜。尽管这些指南在提高儿童蔬菜摄入量方面取得了一定的成效,但仍需要开发新的方法来解决这一问题。在幼儿园/日托中心的早餐时间为儿童提供蔬菜,有可能增加儿童的整体日常蔬菜摄入量,因为儿童通常会在幼儿园/日托中心上学,而且许多儿童在那里有规律地吃早餐。然而,这种干预措施(Veggie Brek)对儿童和幼儿园工作人员的可行性和可接受性尚未得到调查。
在英国的八所幼儿园进行了一项可行性和可接受性的聚类随机对照试验(RCT)。所有幼儿园在干预/对照组前后都进行了为期一周的基线和随访阶段。干预幼儿园的工作人员每天在儿童的主要早餐食品旁提供三根生胡萝卜棒和三根黄瓜棒,为期三周。对照组幼儿园为儿童提供他们通常的早餐。可行性通过招募数据和幼儿园工作人员遵循试验方案的能力来评估。可接受性通过儿童在早餐时吃蔬菜的意愿来评估。所有主要结果都根据红绿灯进展标准进行评估。还评估了工作人员通过照片收集数据与使用纸张的偏好。通过与幼儿园工作人员进行半结构化访谈,进一步了解了他们对干预措施的看法。
愿意为符合条件的儿童提供同意的家长/照顾者的招募率为 67.8%(在琥珀色停止-继续标准范围内),共有 351 名儿童参与了八所幼儿园的研究。幼儿园工作人员对该干预措施的可行性和可接受性以及儿童对蔬菜的接受程度均符合绿灯停止-继续标准,在提供蔬菜的情况下,有 62.4%(745/1194)的儿童食用了部分蔬菜。此外,工作人员更喜欢使用纸张报告数据,而不是拍照。
在幼儿园/日托中心的早餐时间为儿童提供蔬菜是可行和可接受的,既受儿童欢迎,也受幼儿园工作人员欢迎。应该通过一项确定性 RCT 来探索该干预措施的全面评估。
NCT05217550。