Romano Carmela, Viola Pietro, Craus Maurizio, Macchia Gabriella, Ferro Milena, Bonome Paolo, Pierro Antonio, Buwenge Milly, Arcelli Alessandra, Morganti Alessio Giuseppe, Deodato Francesco, Cilla Savino
Medical Physics Unit, Gemelli Molise Hospital, Campobasso, Italy.
Radiation Oncology Unit, Gemelli Molise Hospital, Campobasso, Italy.
Med Dosim. 2023;48(3):140-148. doi: 10.1016/j.meddos.2023.02.003. Epub 2023 Mar 27.
Significant improvements in plan quality using automated planning have been previously demonstrated. The aim of this study was to develop an optimal automated class solution for stereotactic radiotherapy (SBRT) planning of prostate cancer using the new Feasibility module implemented in the pinnacle evolution. Twelve patients were retrospectively enrolled in this planning study. Five plans were designed for each patient. Four plans were automatically generated using the 4 proposed templates for SBRT optimization implemented in the new pinnacle evolution treatment planning systems, differing for different settings of dose-fallout (low, medium, high and veryhigh). Based on the obtained results, the fifth plan (feas) was generated customizing the template with the optimal criteria obtained from the previous step and integrating in the template the "a-priori" knowledge of OARs sparing based on the Feasibility module, able to estimate the best possible dose-volume histograms of OARs before starting optimization. Prescribed dose was 35 Gy to the prostate in 5 fractions. All plans were generated with a full volumetric-modulated arc therapy arc and 6MV flattening filter-free beams, and optimized to ensure the same target coverage (95% of the prescription dose to 98% of the target). Plans were assessed according to dosimetric parameters and planning and delivery efficiency. Differences among the plans were evaluated using a Kruskal-Wallis 1-way analysis of variance. The requests for more aggressive objectives for dose falloff parameters (from low to veryhigh) translated in a statistically significant improvement of dose conformity, but at the expense of a dose homogeneity. The best automated plans in terms of best trade-off between target coverage and OARs sparing among the 4 plans automatically generated by the SBRT module were the high plans. The veryhigh plans reported a significant increase of high-doses to prostate, rectum, and bladder that was considered dosimetrically and clinically unacceptable. The feas plans were optimized on the basis on high plans, reporting significant reduction of rectum irradiation; Dmean, and V18 decreased by 19% to 23% (p = 0.031) and 4% to 7% (p = 0.059), respectively. No statistically significant differences were found in femoral heads and penile bulb irradiation for all dosimetric metrics. feas plans showed a significant increase of MU/Gy (mean: 368; p = 0.004), reflecting an increased level of fluence modulation. Thanks to the new efficient optimization engines implemented in pinnacle evolution (L-BFGS and layered graph), mean planning time was decreased to less than 10 minutes for all plans and all techniques. The integration of dose-volume histograms a-priori knowledge provided by the feasibility module in the automated planning process for SBRT planning has shown to significantly improve plan quality compared to generic protocol values as inputs.
此前已有研究表明,使用自动计划可显著提高计划质量。本研究的目的是利用Pinnacle Evolution中实施的新可行性模块,为前列腺癌立体定向放射治疗(SBRT)计划开发一种最佳自动分类解决方案。本计划研究回顾性纳入了12例患者。为每位患者设计了5个计划。使用新的Pinnacle Evolution治疗计划系统中实施的4种用于SBRT优化的建议模板自动生成4个计划,这些模板因剂量下降的不同设置(低、中、高和非常高)而有所不同。根据获得的结果,生成了第五个计划(feas),该计划使用上一步获得的最佳标准定制模板,并将基于可行性模块的OARs保留的“先验”知识整合到模板中,能够在开始优化之前估计OARs的最佳剂量体积直方图。前列腺的处方剂量为35 Gy,分5次给予。所有计划均采用全容积调强弧形治疗弧和6MV无均整器光束生成,并进行优化以确保相同的靶区覆盖(处方剂量的95%至靶区的98%)。根据剂量学参数以及计划和交付效率对计划进行评估。使用Kruskal-Wallis单向方差分析评估计划之间的差异。对剂量下降参数提出更激进目标的要求(从低到非常高)转化为剂量适形性的统计学显著改善,但以剂量均匀性为代价。在SBRT模块自动生成的4个计划中,就靶区覆盖和OARs保留之间的最佳权衡而言,最佳自动计划是高剂量计划。非常高剂量计划显示前列腺、直肠和膀胱的高剂量显著增加,这在剂量学和临床上被认为是不可接受的。feas计划在高剂量计划的基础上进行了优化,直肠照射显著减少;Dmean和V18分别降低了19%至23%(p = 0.031)和4%至7%(p = 0.059)。对于所有剂量学指标,股骨头和阴茎球部照射未发现统计学显著差异。feas计划显示MU/Gy显著增加(平均值:368;p = 0.004),反映了通量调制水平的提高。由于Pinnacle Evolution中实施了新的高效优化引擎(L-BFGS和分层图),所有计划和所有技术的平均计划时间均降至不到10分钟。与作为输入的通用协议值相比,在SBRT计划的自动计划过程中整合可行性模块提供的剂量体积直方图先验知识已显示出可显著提高计划质量。