Zhu Junhao, Cong Zixiang, Ma Chiyuan
Department of Neurosurgery, Affiliated Jinling Hospital, Medical School of Nanjing University, China.
School of medicine, Nanjing Medical University, China.
World Neurosurg X. 2023 Mar 20;18:100179. doi: 10.1016/j.wnsx.2023.100179. eCollection 2023 Apr.
Cavernous sinus hemangiomas (CSHs) are hypervascular malformations and the surgical treatment is technically demanding. Although some articles have reported resection of CSHs using endoscopic endonasal transsphenoidal surgery (EETS), most of them were encountered for a lack of preoperative strategy guidance. Herein, we reported gross total resection (GTR) of intrasellar CSHs in two patients undergoing strategical EETS and compared EETS with frontotemporal craniotomy (FC) and stereotactic radiosurgery by literature review.
Two patients with CSHs who underwent EETS were reported. The literature review was conducted to exhaust studies that reported surgical treatment for CSHs. The tumor resection rate, and the postoperative short-term and long-term newly-developed or deteriorative cranial-nerve function rates were extracted.
GTR was achieved with no postoperative complications in the two cases. Nine articles reported 14 cases undergoing EETS for CSHs and twenty-three articles reported 195 cases undergoing FC for CSHs. The GTR rates of EETS and FC were 57.14% (8/14) and 78.97% (154/195) respectively. The postoperative short-term and long-term newly-developed or deteriorative cranial-nerve function rates were 0% (0/7) and 0% (0/6) for the EETS group, and 57% (57/100) and 18.18% (18/99) for the FC group. According to the previous meta-analysis, stereotactic radiosurgery resulted in remarkable tumor shrinkage in 67.80% (40/59) of patients and partial shrinkage in 25.42% of patients.
The results showed that the intrasellar type of CSHs could be removed safely by EETS without crossing the nerves in the CS.
海绵窦血管瘤(CSHs)是高血管性畸形,手术治疗技术要求高。尽管有一些文章报道了使用鼻内镜经鼻蝶窦手术(EETS)切除CSHs,但大多数缺乏术前策略指导。在此,我们报告了2例接受策略性EETS的鞍内CSHs患者的全切除情况,并通过文献综述将EETS与额颞开颅术(FC)和立体定向放射外科手术进行比较。
报告2例接受EETS的CSHs患者。进行文献综述以穷尽报道CSHs手术治疗的研究。提取肿瘤切除率以及术后短期和长期新出现或恶化的颅神经功能率。
2例均实现全切除且无术后并发症。9篇文章报道了14例接受EETS治疗CSHs的病例,23篇文章报道了195例接受FC治疗CSHs的病例。EETS和FC的全切除率分别为57.14%(8/14)和78.97%(154/195)。EETS组术后短期和长期新出现或恶化的颅神经功能率分别为0%(0/7)和0%(0/6),FC组分别为57%(57/100)和18.18%(18/99)。根据先前的荟萃分析,立体定向放射外科手术使67.80%(40/59)的患者肿瘤显著缩小,25.42%的患者部分缩小。
结果表明,鞍内型CSHs可通过EETS安全切除,且不穿过海绵窦内的神经。