Rance Gary, Dowell Richard C, Tomlin Dani
The University of Melbourne, Department of Audiology and Speech Pathology, Parkville, VIC, Australia.
NPJ Sci Learn. 2023 Apr 3;8(1):9. doi: 10.1038/s41539-023-00157-y.
The physical characteristics of a child's learning environment can affect health, wellbeing and educational progress. Here we investigate the effect of classroom setting on academic progress in 7-10-year-old students comparing reading development in "open-plan" (multiple class groups located within one physical space) and "enclosed-plan" (one class group per space) environments. All learning conditions (class group, teaching personnel, etc.) were held constant throughout, while physical environment was alternated term-by-term using a portable, sound-treated dividing wall. One hundred and ninety-six students underwent academic, cognitive and auditory assessment at baseline and 146 of these were available for repeat assessment at the completion of 3 school terms, allowing within-child changes across an academic year to be calculated. Reading fluency development (change in words read-per-minute) was greater for the enclosed-classroom phases (P < 0.001; 95%CI 3.7, 10.0) and the children who showed the greatest condition difference (i.e. slower rate of development in the open-plan) were those with the worst speech perception in noise and/or poorest attention skills. These findings highlight the important role classroom setting plays in the academic development of young students.
儿童学习环境的物理特征会影响其健康、幸福和学业进展。在此,我们研究了教室环境对7至10岁学生学业进展的影响,比较了“开放式布局”(多个班级组位于一个物理空间内)和“封闭式布局”(每个空间一个班级组)环境下的阅读发展情况。所有学习条件(班级组、教学人员等)在整个过程中保持不变,而物理环境则使用便携式隔音分隔墙逐学期交替。196名学生在基线时接受了学业、认知和听觉评估,其中146名学生在3个学期结束时可进行重复评估,从而能够计算一学年内儿童自身的变化情况。封闭式教室阶段的阅读流畅性发展(每分钟阅读单词数的变化)更大(P < 0.001;95%CI 3.7,10.0),而条件差异最大(即在开放式布局中发展速度较慢)的儿童是那些在噪声中语音感知最差和/或注意力技能最差的儿童。这些发现凸显了教室环境在年幼学生学业发展中所起的重要作用。