Surgical Simulation Research Lab, Department of Surgery, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Department of Breast Surgery, The First Hospital of Shanxi Medical University, Taiyuan, China.
Surg Innov. 2023 Aug;30(4):517-525. doi: 10.1177/15533506231169067. Epub 2023 Apr 4.
Heavy muscle load during operations, caused by static and awkward postures, contributes to the discomfort of surgeons, and imperils surgical quality. We reviewed the supporting devices available to assist surgeons in the operating room and anticipated that physical support devices would help reduce occupational injuries among surgeons and improve surgical performance.
A systematic literature review was completed. Papers on supporting devices for intraoperative stress reduction were included. Supported body parts and the impact of these devices on the surgeons' performance were extracted from the 21 selected papers.
Among the 21 devices introduced, eleven targeted on the upper extremities, 5 targeted on the lower extremities, and 5 were ergonomic chairs. Nine devices were tested in the operating room, 10 in a lab setting with simulated tasks, and 2 were still in development. The data from 7 studies did not show a significant improvement in stress reduction or surgical quality. With 2 devices still in the development phase, the remaining 12 papers showed promising results.
Although some of the devices were still in testing, most of the research teams believed that physical supporting devices can be useful in reducing muscle load, relieving discomfort, and improving surgical performance intraoperatively.
手术过程中由于静态和不舒适的姿势导致的肌肉负重过重,会增加外科医生的不适,并危及手术质量。我们回顾了可用于协助手术室外科医生的支撑设备,并预计物理支撑设备将有助于减少外科医生的职业伤害并提高手术表现。
完成了系统的文献综述。纳入了关于术中减轻压力的支撑设备的论文。从 21 篇选定的论文中提取了支撑身体部位以及这些设备对外科医生表现的影响。
在介绍的 21 种设备中,有 11 种针对上肢,5 种针对下肢,5 种为符合人体工程学的椅子。有 9 种设备在手术室中进行了测试,10 种在具有模拟任务的实验室环境中进行了测试,还有 2 种仍在开发中。7 项研究的数据并未显示在减轻压力或手术质量方面有显著改善。由于有 2 种设备仍处于开发阶段,其余 12 篇论文显示出了有前景的结果。
尽管有些设备仍在测试中,但大多数研究团队认为,物理支撑设备在减少肌肉负荷、缓解不适和提高手术过程中的手术表现方面可能是有用的。