Department of Sociology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA.
Demography. 2023 Jun 1;60(3):761-784. doi: 10.1215/00703370-10653728.
What is the relationship between gender segregation in higher education and gender segregation in the labor market? Using Fossett's (2017) difference-of-means method for calculating segregation indices and data from the American Community Survey, we show that approximately 36% of occupational segregation among college-educated workers is associated with gender segregation across 173 fields of study, and roughly 64% reflects gender segregation within fields. A decomposition analysis shows that fields contribute to occupational segregation mainly through endowment effects (men's and women's uneven distribution across fields) than through the coefficient effects (gender differences in the likelihood of entering a male-dominated occupation from the same field). Endowment effects are highest in fields strongly linked to the labor market, suggesting that educational segregation among fields in which graduates tend to enter a limited set of occupations is particularly consequential for occupational segregation. Within-field occupational segregation is higher among heavily male-dominated fields than other fields, but it does not vary systematically by fields' STEM status or field-occupation linkage strength. Assuming the relationship between field segregation and occupational segregation is at least partly causal, these results imply that integrating higher education (e.g., by increasing women's representation in STEM majors) will reduce but not eliminate gender segregation in labor markets.
高等教育中的性别隔离与劳动力市场中的性别隔离之间存在什么关系?利用 Fossett(2017)计算隔离指数的均值差异法和美国社区调查的数据,我们表明,在受过大学教育的劳动者中,约有 36%的职业隔离与 173 个学科领域的性别隔离有关,而大约 64%的职业隔离反映了领域内的性别隔离。分解分析表明,领域主要通过禀赋效应(男女在领域之间的分布不均)而不是系数效应(来自同一领域的男性主导职业的性别差异)对职业隔离产生影响。在与劳动力市场紧密相关的领域中,禀赋效应最高,这表明在毕业生倾向于进入有限职业的领域中,教育隔离对职业隔离的影响尤为重要。在以男性为主导的领域中,领域内的职业隔离程度高于其他领域,但它并不随着领域的 STEM 地位或领域与职业联系的强弱而系统地变化。假设领域隔离与职业隔离之间的关系至少部分是因果关系,那么这些结果表明,整合高等教育(例如,增加女性在 STEM 专业中的代表性)将减少但不能消除劳动力市场中的性别隔离。