Firestone Philip, Crowe David, Goodman John T, McGrath Patrick
School of Psychology.
Queensway Carleton Hospital.
Am J Orthopsychiatry. 1986 Apr;56(2):184-194. doi: 10.1111/j.1939-0025.1986.tb02718.x.
A two-year outcome study of 73 hyperactive children supports both previous short-term studies which suggested that stimulant medication is superior to parent training and long-term studies which found no differences between the two interventions. The discrepancy is discussed in light of complications that inevitably arise in outcome studies and that tend to preclude meaningful outcomes in long-term studies. The development of new research strategies is called for.
一项针对73名多动症儿童的两年期结果研究,既支持了之前的短期研究(该研究表明兴奋剂药物治疗优于家长培训),也支持了长期研究(该研究发现两种干预措施之间没有差异)。鉴于在结果研究中不可避免地会出现并发症,且这些并发症往往会妨碍长期研究得出有意义的结果,本文对这种差异进行了讨论。文中呼吁开发新的研究策略。