Orru' Stefano, Oberle Doris, Heiden Margarethe, Müller Susanne, Krut Oleg, Funk Markus Benedikt
Safety of Medicinal Products and Medical Devices Division, Paul-Ehrlich-Institut, Langen, Germany.
Microbiological Safety Section, Paul-Ehrlich-Institut, Langen, Germany.
Transfus Med Hemother. 2022 Dec 29;50(2):144-153. doi: 10.1159/000526761. eCollection 2023 Apr.
Following the first assessment of the effects of safety measures taken against transfusion-transmitted bacterial infections (TTBI), the Paul-Ehrlich-Institut (PEI) decided to newly analyze risk minimization measures (RMM) using German hemovigilance data from 2011 to 2020, focusing on blood components, recipients, and bacterial strains.
The PEI assessed the imputability of all reported serious adverse reactions (SAR) relying mainly on microbiological test results. Reporting rates (RR) of suspected, confirmed, and fatal confirmed TTBI were calculated and compared to the previous reporting 10-year period (2001-2010) using Poisson regression to estimate RR ratios (RRR). Furthermore, details on blood component age, patients' medical history, and bacterial pathogenicity were collected.
With respect to the previous 10-year period, the number of suspected TTBI increased ( = 403), while fewer cases were confirmed ( = 40); the number of deaths remained more or less unchanged ( = 8). The RR for suspected TTBI were 7.9, 18.7, and 1.6 cases per million units transfused for red blood cells (RBC), platelet concentrates (PC), and fresh frozen plasma (FFP), respectively. RRR showed a statistically significant 2.5-fold increase in the RR for suspected TTBI after RBC administration from 2001-2010 to the period under review ( < 0.0001). The RR for confirmed TTBI were 0.4, 5.0, and 0.0 cases per million units transfused for RBC, PC, and FFP, respectively. Compared to the period 2001-2010, there was a statistically significant decrease in the RR of confirmed TTBI by half for PC ( = 0.0052). The RR for confirmed PC-caused TTBI with fatal outcome was 1.4 cases per million units transfused. Regardless of type of blood product transfused and outcome of SAR, the majority of TTBI occurred after administration of a product at the end of shelf life (40.0%) and to recipients of advanced age (median age: 68.5 years) and/or with severe immunosuppression (72.5%) due to decreased myelopoiesis (62.5%). 72.5% of the involved bacteria had a middle/high human pathogenicity.
Despite a significant decrease in confirmed TTBI following PC transfusion in Germany after implementation of RMM, the current manufacture of blood products can still not prevent TTBI with fatal outcomes. As demonstrated in various countries, RMM like bacterial screening or pathogen reduction may measurably improve the safety of blood transfusion.
在首次评估针对输血传播细菌感染(TTBI)所采取安全措施的效果之后,保罗·埃利希研究所(PEI)决定利用2011年至2020年德国血液监测数据,重新分析风险最小化措施(RMM),重点关注血液成分、受血者和细菌菌株。
PEI主要依据微生物检测结果评估所有报告的严重不良反应(SAR)的可归因性。计算疑似、确诊和致命确诊TTBI的报告率(RR),并使用泊松回归估计RR比(RRR),与之前的10年报告期(2001 - 2010年)进行比较。此外,收集了血液成分保存期限、患者病史和细菌致病性的详细信息。
与前一个10年期间相比,疑似TTBI的数量增加了( = 403),而确诊病例减少了( = 40);死亡人数基本保持不变( = 8)。每百万单位红细胞(RBC)、浓缩血小板(PC)和新鲜冰冻血浆(FFP)输注中,疑似TTBI的RR分别为7.9、18.7和1.6例。RRR显示,从2001 - 2010年到本审查期,RBC输注后疑似TTBI的RR有统计学显著的2.5倍增加( < 0.0001)。每百万单位RBC、PC和FFP输注中,确诊TTBI的RR分别为0.4、5.0和0.0例。与2001 - 2010年期间相比,PC确诊TTBI的RR在统计学上显著下降了一半( = 0.0052)。每百万单位输注中,确诊由PC导致的致命性TTBI的RR为1.4例。无论输注的血液制品类型和SAR结果如何,大多数TTBI发生在使用保质期结束时的产品后(40.0%),以及输注给高龄受血者(中位年龄:68.5岁)和/或因骨髓生成减少(62.5%)而严重免疫抑制的受血者(72.5%)。72.5%的相关细菌具有中/高人类致病性。
尽管在德国实施RMM后PC输血后确诊TTBI显著减少,但目前血液制品的生产仍无法预防致命性TTBI。正如在各国所表明的,细菌筛查或病原体灭活等RMM可显著提高输血安全性。