National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, Kawasaki, Japan.
PLoS One. 2023 Apr 19;18(4):e0284465. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0284465. eCollection 2023.
A quarter of work-related low back pain (LBP) cases result from handling heavy loads in Japan. The maximum weight male/female workers can handle is 40%/24% of their body weight but has set a constant load weight in ISO 11228-1 and NIOSH lifting equation. The preventive effect of the relative weight limit on LBP has not been clarified. This study aimed to identify the effect of relative weight limits set as body weight percentages on LBP prevalence.
Data from 21924 workers were collected via a web-based survey in 2022. The workers were categorized into three groups: group A, "no handling," group B, "handling loads up to 40%/24% or less of body weight," and group C, "handling loads over 40%/24% of body weight." Moreover, they were categorized into eight groups: no handling, 1-5 kg, 5-10 kg, 10-15 kg, 15-20 kg, 20-25 kg, 25-30 kg, and ≥30 kg. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used to identify the effects of the limits set to body weight percentages and constant load weights on LBP.
In groups A, B, and C, 25.5%, 39.2%, and 47.3% of males or 16.9%, 26.4%, and 38.0% of females had LBP, respectively. The odds ratio (OR) of LBP was significantly greater in group B than in group A and even greater in group C. The OR of LBP among workers handling loads under 10 kg was not significantly different compared to no-handling workers.
LBP prevalence was greater in group B than in group A but lesser than in group C. Weight limits based on body weight percentages could not eliminate the factor of handling loads. However, handling loads under 10 kg suppressed LBP. Relative weight limits set as body weight percentages were inappropriate and ineffective for preventing LBP.
在日本,四分之一的与工作相关的下背痛(LBP)病例是由于搬运重物引起的。男性/女性工人可搬运的最大重量分别为其体重的 40%/24%,但 ISO 11228-1 和 NIOSH 提升方程中设定了恒定的负载重量。相对重量限制对 LBP 的预防效果尚未明确。本研究旨在确定设定为体重百分比的相对重量限制对 LBP 患病率的影响。
2022 年通过网络调查收集了 21924 名工人的数据。工人分为三组:A 组,“无搬运”;B 组,“搬运负荷不超过体重的 40%/24%或以下”;C 组,“搬运负荷超过体重的 40%/24%”。此外,他们还分为无搬运、1-5 公斤、5-10 公斤、10-15 公斤、15-20 公斤、20-25 公斤、25-30 公斤和≥30 公斤八个组。采用多变量逻辑回归分析来确定设定为体重百分比和恒定负载重量的限制对 LBP 的影响。
在 A、B 和 C 组中,男性分别有 25.5%、39.2%和 47.3%或女性分别有 16.9%、26.4%和 38.0%患有 LBP。与 A 组相比,B 组的 LBP 比值比(OR)显著更高,与 C 组相比,甚至更高。与无搬运工人相比,处理负荷低于 10 公斤的工人的 LBP OR 没有显著差异。
B 组的 LBP 患病率高于 A 组,但低于 C 组。基于体重百分比的重量限制不能消除搬运负荷的因素。然而,处理 10 公斤以下的负荷可以抑制 LBP。设定为体重百分比的相对重量限制是不合适和无效的,不能预防 LBP。