Graham Kathryn, Bernards Sharon, Abbey Antonia, Senn Charlene, Dumas Tara M, Trudell AnnaLise, Donnelly Peter D, Wells Samantha
Institute for Mental Health Policy Research, Campbell Family Mental Health Research Institute, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, London/Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res (Hoboken). 2023 Jun;47(6):1191-1203. doi: 10.1111/acer.15087. Epub 2023 Apr 27.
Sexual aggression (SA) is ubiquitous in drinking environments. Although such behavior is often seen as normal and acceptable, the targets of SA experience many negative consequences. This research aimed to develop a valid measure of common acts of SA in drinking settings for estimating prevalence and evaluating prevention initiatives.
We developed a questionnaire measure of common acts of sexual harassment and aggression in drinking environments (C-SHADE) based on descriptions of SA behavior from our own and others' research. The measure was validated in a cross-sectional survey of 335 men aged 19 to 25 using webpanels from an online survey company. Validation measures included: a modified version of the Sexual Experiences Survey (M-SES), measures of SA by peers in drinking environments, SA-related attitudes, expectancies about sexual effects of alcohol, and alcohol consumption.
The C-SHADE showed high internal consistency (α = 0.96) and was significantly correlated with M-SES (r = 0.52), SA by peers (r = 0.61 to 0.70), SA-related attitudes/expectations (r = 0.38 to 0.55), and measures of alcohol consumption (r = 0.22 to 0.36). Overall, 71.9% of participants reported SA using the C-SHADE versus 24.7% with the M-SES. We compared the responses of participants who reported perpetration on both measures (N = 83), on only the C-SHADE (N = 141), and among nonperpetrators (N = 89; excluding four participants who reported perpetration only on the M-SES). The M-SES/C-SHADE perpetrators scored significantly higher than C-SHADE-only perpetrators and nonperpetrators on most SA-related and drinking measures, while C-SHADE-only perpetrators scored significantly higher than nonperpetrators on peer SA and two attitude measures.
The C-SHADE is suitable for measuring prevalence and evaluating interventions in drinking settings. The C-SHADE confirmed a high prevalence of SA in drinking settings and identified an important group of C-SHADE-only perpetrators for whom interventions that focus on situational precipitators of SA in drinking settings may be especially useful.
性侵犯在饮酒环境中普遍存在。尽管这种行为通常被视为正常且可接受的,但性侵犯的受害者会经历许多负面后果。本研究旨在开发一种有效的测量饮酒场景中常见性侵犯行为的方法,以估计其发生率并评估预防措施。
我们根据自己和他人研究中对性侵犯行为的描述,开发了一种饮酒环境中性骚扰和侵犯常见行为的问卷调查量表(C-SHADE)。该量表在对335名年龄在19至25岁的男性进行的横断面调查中得到验证,调查使用了一家在线调查公司的网络面板。验证指标包括:性经历调查的修订版(M-SES)、饮酒环境中同伴的性侵犯测量、与性侵犯相关的态度、对酒精性影响的预期以及酒精消费情况。
C-SHADE显示出较高的内部一致性(α = 0.96),并且与M-SES(r = 0.52)、同伴的性侵犯(r = 0.61至0.70)、与性侵犯相关的态度/预期(r = 0.38至0.55)以及酒精消费测量(r = 0.22至0.36)显著相关。总体而言,使用C-SHADE报告有性侵犯行为的参与者占71.9%,而使用M-SES的这一比例为24.7%。我们比较了在两种测量方法上都报告有犯罪行为的参与者(N = 83)、仅在C-SHADE上报告有犯罪行为的参与者(N = 141)以及非犯罪者(N = 89;不包括仅在M-SES上报告有犯罪行为的四名参与者)的回答。在大多数与性侵犯相关和饮酒的测量指标上,M-SES/C-SHADE犯罪者的得分显著高于仅C-SHADE犯罪者和非犯罪者,而仅C-SHADE犯罪者在同伴性侵犯和两项态度测量指标上的得分显著高于非犯罪者。
C-SHADE适用于测量饮酒场景中的发生率并评估干预措施。C-SHADE证实了饮酒场景中性侵犯的高发生率,并确定了一个重要的仅C-SHADE犯罪者群体,针对他们的干预措施可能特别有用,这些干预措施侧重于饮酒场景中性侵犯的情境诱因。