Phillips Frank, Crowley Jane, Warburton Samantha, Staniforth Karren, Parra-Blanco Adolfo, Gordon George S D
NIHR Nottingham Biomedical Research Centre Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust and the University of Nottingham Nottingham UK.
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering University of Nottingham Nottingham UK.
DEN Open. 2023 Apr 17;3(1):e231. doi: 10.1002/deo2.231. eCollection 2023 Apr.
Upper gastrointestinal endoscopies are aerosol-generating procedures, increasing the risk of spreading airborne pathogens. We aim to quantify the mitigation of airborne particles via improved ventilation, specifically laminar flow theatres and portable high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters, during and after upper gastrointestinal endoscopies.
This observational study included patients undergoing routine upper gastrointestinal endoscopy in a standard endoscopy room with 15-17 air changes per hour, a standard endoscopy room with a portable HEPA filtration unit, and a laminar flow theatre with 300 air changes per hour. A particle counter (diameter range 0.3 μm-25 μm) took measurements 10 cm from the mouth. Three analyses were performed: whole procedure particle counts, event-based counts, and air clearance estimation using post-procedure counts.
Compared to a standard endoscopy room, for whole procedures we observe a 28.5x reduction in particle counts in laminar flow ( < 0.001) but no significant effect of HEPA filtration ( = 0.50). For event analysis, we observe for lateral flow theatres reduction in particles >5 μm for oral extubation (12.2x, < 0.01), reduction in particles <5 μm for coughing/gagging (6.9x, < 0.05), and reduction for all sizes in anesthetic throat spray (8.4x, < 0.01) but no significant effect of HEPA filtration. However, we find that in the fallow period between procedures HEPA filtration reduces particle clearance times by 40%.
Laminar flow theatres are highly effective at dispersing aerosols immediately after production and should be considered for high-risk cases where patients are actively infectious or the supply of personal protective equipment is limited. Portable HEPA filers can safely reduce the fallow time between procedures by 40%.
上消化道内镜检查是产生气溶胶的操作,会增加空气传播病原体扩散的风险。我们旨在量化通过改善通风,特别是层流手术室和便携式高效空气过滤器(HEPA),在上消化道内镜检查期间及之后对空气中颗粒的缓解作用。
这项观察性研究纳入了在每小时换气15 - 17次的标准内镜检查室、配备便携式HEPA过滤装置的标准内镜检查室以及每小时换气300次的层流手术室接受常规上消化道内镜检查的患者。一台粒子计数器(直径范围0.3μm - 25μm)在距口腔10厘米处进行测量。进行了三项分析:整个操作过程中的颗粒计数、基于事件的计数以及使用操作后计数进行的空气清除估计。
与标准内镜检查室相比,对于整个操作过程,我们观察到层流中颗粒计数减少了28.5倍(P < 0.001),但HEPA过滤没有显著效果(P = 0.50)。对于事件分析,我们观察到层流手术室在拔管时大于5μm的颗粒减少(12.2倍,P < 0.01),咳嗽/作呕时小于5μm的颗粒减少(6.9倍,P < 0.05),以及麻醉咽喉喷雾时所有尺寸的颗粒减少(8.4倍,P < 0.01),但HEPA过滤没有显著效果。然而,我们发现操作间隙期HEPA过滤可将颗粒清除时间缩短40%。
层流手术室在气溶胶产生后能非常有效地驱散气溶胶,对于患者处于活动感染期或个人防护装备供应有限的高风险病例应予以考虑。便携式HEPA过滤器可安全地将操作间隙时间缩短40%。