Zhou Chenhong, Gao Meng, Li Jianjun, Bai Kaixu, Tang Xiao, Lu Xiao, Liu Cheng, Wang Zifa, Guo Yike
Department of Computer Science, Faculty of Science, Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong Kong SAR 999077, China.
Department of Geography, Faculty of Social Sciences, Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong Kong SAR 999077, China.
ACS Environ Au. 2022 Mar 10;2(4):314-323. doi: 10.1021/acsenvironau.1c00051. eCollection 2022 Jul 20.
A myriad of studies have attempted to use ground-level observations to obtain gap-free spatiotemporal variations of PM, in support of air quality management and impact studies. Statistical methods (machine learning, etc.) or numerical methods by combining chemical transport modeling and observations with data assimilation techniques have been typically applied, yet the significance of site placement has not been well recognized. In this study, we apply five proper orthogonal decomposition (POD)-based sensor placement algorithms to identify optimal site locations and systematically evaluate their reconstruction ability. We demonstrate that the QR pivot is relatively more reliable in deciding optimal monitoring site locations. When the number of planned sites (sensors) is limited, using a lower number of modes would yield lower estimation errors. However, the dimension of POD modes has little impact on reconstruction quality when sufficient sensors are available. The locations of sites guided by the QR pivot algorithm are mainly located in regions where PM pollution is severe. We compare reconstructed PM pollution based on QR pivot-guided sites and existing China National Environmental Monitoring Center (CNEMC) sites and find that the QR pivot-guided sites are superior to existing sites with respect to reconstruction accuracy. The current planning of monitoring stations is likely to miss sources of pollution in less-populated regions, while our QR pivot-guided sites are planned based on the severity of PM pollution. This planning methodology has additional potentials in chemical data assimilation studies as duplicate information from current CNEMC-concentrated stations is not likely to boost performance.
大量研究试图利用地面观测来获取颗粒物(PM)无间隙的时空变化,以支持空气质量管控和影响研究。通常采用统计方法(机器学习等)或通过将化学传输模型与观测数据以及数据同化技术相结合的数值方法,但监测站点布局的重要性尚未得到充分认识。在本研究中,我们应用了五种基于本征正交分解(POD)的传感器布局算法来确定最佳站点位置,并系统地评估它们的重建能力。我们证明,在确定最佳监测站点位置方面,QR 枢轴相对更可靠。当计划设置的站点(传感器)数量有限时,使用较少数量的模态会产生较低的估计误差。然而,当有足够的传感器时,POD 模态的维度对重建质量影响不大。由 QR 枢轴算法引导的站点位置主要位于 PM 污染严重的区域。我们比较了基于 QR 枢轴引导的站点和中国国家环境监测中心(CNEMC)现有站点重建的 PM 污染情况,发现 QR 枢轴引导的站点在重建精度方面优于现有站点。当前监测站的布局可能会遗漏人口较少地区的污染源,而我们基于 QR 枢轴引导的站点是根据 PM 污染的严重程度规划的。这种规划方法在化学数据同化研究中还有额外的潜力,因为来自当前 CNEMC 集中站点的重复信息不太可能提高性能。