J Opt Soc Am A Opt Image Sci Vis. 2023 Mar 1;40(3):A91-A98. doi: 10.1364/JOSAA.477206.
This work expands on our previous comparison of the Konan-Waggoner D15 (KW-D15) and Farnsworth D15 (F-D15). Sixty subjects with normal color vision and 68 subjects with a red-green color vision defect participated in the study. The KW-D15 had good agreement with the F-D15 for both pass/fail and classification across all failure criteria. The agreement was slightly better if subjects had to pass on 2/3 trials compared with just the first trial. The KW-D15 is an adequate substitute for the F-D15, with the caveat that the KW-D15 might be slightly easier to pass than the F-D15 for deutans.
本研究扩展了我们之前对 Konan-Waggoner D15(KW-D15)和 Farnsworth D15(F-D15)的比较。60 名正常色觉受试者和 68 名红绿色觉缺陷受试者参与了这项研究。对于所有的失败标准,KW-D15 在通过/失败和分类方面与 F-D15 都有很好的一致性。如果受试者必须通过 2/3 的试验,而不仅仅是第一次试验,那么一致性会更好一些。KW-D15 是 F-D15 的一个很好的替代品,但需要注意的是,对于弱色觉者来说,KW-D15 可能比 F-D15 稍微容易通过。