Leong-Nowell Tamara Ah, Tamani Ledua, Kaspar Annette
School of Public Health and Primary Care, Fiji National University, Suva, Fiji.
Samoa Medical Association, Apia, Samoa.
Int J Emerg Med. 2023 May 8;16(1):32. doi: 10.1186/s12245-023-00512-1.
Access block and overcrowding are known to adversely impact on patient outcomes, service delivery, and patient experiences within emergency departments (ED) worldwide. There are no studies on access block or overcrowding from the Pacific Islands. The aim of the present study is to provide preliminary data on access block and overcrowding in the ED of the national tertiary hospital of Samoa.
Mixed methods study design. Data collection was performed in March 2020. The quantitative strand calculated (1) the point prevalence of patients impacted by access block in the ED, and (2) the ED bed occupancy rate to assess for overcrowding. The qualitative strand used thematic analysis of two focus group interviews exploring access block and overcrowding with ED medical and nursing staff members.
On the day of data collection, a total of 60 patients presented through the ED triage system. Of the 20 patients who were admitted into ED, 80% were triaged as 'see without delay' (CAT1), 'emergency' (CAT2) or 'urgent' (CAT3). For patients requiring admission to hospital wards, 100% waited 4 + h in ED, and 100% waited 8 + h, suggesting the presence of access block. Overcrowding in the ED setting was also evident, with an ED bed occupancy rate of 0.95, and an adjusted bed occupancy rate of 1.43. The major themes emerging from the ED staff focus groups and individual in-depth interviews were (1) the adverse impacts of access block and overcrowding, i.e., violence towards ED staff members, (2) the preventable contributing factors, i.e., lack of physical beds in the ED, and (3) practical recommendations to improve patient flow through the ED, i.e., improved collaboration between ED, outpatient services, and the hospital wards.
Preliminary evidence suggested the presence of access block and overcrowding in the ED of the national tertiary hospital of Samoa. ED staff interviews provided insight into the ED frontline challenges and offered practical recommendations for ED health service improvement.
在全球范围内,急诊部门的就诊受阻和过度拥挤已知会对患者治疗结果、服务提供以及患者体验产生不利影响。目前尚无来自太平洋岛屿地区关于就诊受阻或过度拥挤情况的研究。本研究的目的是提供萨摩亚国家三级医院急诊科就诊受阻和过度拥挤情况的初步数据。
采用混合方法研究设计。数据收集于2020年3月进行。定量研究部分计算了(1)急诊科中受就诊受阻影响的患者的时点患病率,以及(2)急诊科床位占用率以评估是否存在过度拥挤。定性研究部分对两个焦点小组访谈进行了主题分析,访谈对象为急诊科医护人员,探讨就诊受阻和过度拥挤问题。
在数据收集当天,共有60名患者通过急诊科分诊系统就诊。在20名被收治入急诊科的患者中,80%被分诊为“立即就诊”(1类)、“紧急”(2类)或“ urgent”(3类)。对于需要住院病房治疗的患者,100%在急诊科等待了4小时以上,100%等待了8小时以上,这表明存在就诊受阻情况。急诊科的过度拥挤情况也很明显,急诊科床位占用率为0.95,调整后的床位占用率为1.43。急诊科工作人员焦点小组和个人深度访谈中出现的主要主题包括:(1)就诊受阻和过度拥挤的不利影响,即对急诊科工作人员的暴力行为;(2)可预防的促成因素,即急诊科缺乏实际床位;(3)改善患者在急诊科就诊流程的实用建议,即急诊科、门诊服务和医院病房之间加强协作。
初步证据表明,萨摩亚国家三级医院急诊科存在就诊受阻和过度拥挤情况。对急诊科工作人员的访谈深入了解了急诊科一线面临的挑战,并为改善急诊科医疗服务提供了实用建议。