Dekkers Laura M B, Isik Ulviye, Sanders C J G, Dilaver Gönül
UMC Utrecht, Onderwijscentrum Biomedische Wetenschappen,Utrecht.
UMC Utrecht, Onderwijscentrum Biomedische Wetenschappen, Utrecht.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 2023 May 10;167:D7332.
Within diverse populations such as in the Netherlands, medical education must prepare students to diagnose skin conditions on a broad range of skin tones. To develop the visual pattern recognition skills to do so, medical students need exposure to skin conditions on deeper skin tones. The purpose of this study is to assess the inclusion of images of brown skin in Dutch dermatology textbooks.
Observational study.
Two large Dutch student textbook web shops were searched for dermatology textbooks, and all available general dermatology textbooks explicitly aimed at medical students were selected. All images of skin were examined and divided into the categories 'light skin', 'light to medium brown skin', 'medium to deep brown skin', 'deep to very deep brown skin', and 'indeterminate'.
Five textbooks, with a total of 2060 images of skin, were examined. 87.6% of images showed light skin, 7.0% showed light to medium brown skin, 2.9% showed medium to deep brown skin, and 0.5% showed deep to very deep brown skin. 2.0% was categorized as 'indeterminate'.
Dutch dermatology textbooks currently include only small percentages of images of brown skin. Unfamiliarity with disease presentation on deeper skin tones can lead to delayed diagnosis and worse outcomes in Black and Brown patients. Future textbooks should include images of different skin tones, including deeper ones, for every skin condition.
在荷兰这样的多元化人群中,医学教育必须让学生做好准备,能够诊断各种肤色人群的皮肤疾病。为了培养进行此类诊断的视觉模式识别技能,医学生需要接触深肤色人群的皮肤疾病。本研究的目的是评估荷兰皮肤病学教科书中棕色皮肤图像的收录情况。
观察性研究。
在两家大型荷兰学生教科书网上商店搜索皮肤病学教科书,并挑选出所有明确面向医学生的通用皮肤病学教科书。检查所有皮肤图像,并将其分为“浅色皮肤”“浅至中度棕色皮肤”“中度至深棕色皮肤”“深至非常深棕色皮肤”以及“不确定”几类。
共检查了五本教科书,其中包含2060张皮肤图像。87.6%的图像展示的是浅色皮肤,7.0%展示的是浅至中度棕色皮肤,2.9%展示的是中度至深棕色皮肤,0.5%展示的是深至非常深棕色皮肤。2.0%被归类为“不确定”。
荷兰皮肤病学教科书目前收录的棕色皮肤图像比例很小。对深肤色人群疾病表现不熟悉可能导致黑人和棕色人种患者诊断延迟和预后更差。未来的教科书应针对每种皮肤疾病收录不同肤色的图像,包括深肤色图像。