Department of Clinical Genomics, The University of Tokyo Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
Next-Generation Precision Medicine Development Laboratory, Graduate School of Medicine, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Cancer Sci. 2023 Jul;114(7):3041-3049. doi: 10.1111/cas.15833. Epub 2023 May 10.
Comprehensive genomic profiling (CGP) tests have been nationally reimbursed in Japan since June 2019 under strict restrictions, and over 46,000 patients have taken the test. Core Hospitals and Designated Hospitals host molecular tumor boards, which is more time-consuming than simply participating in them. We sent a questionnaire to government-designated Cancer Genomic Medicine Hospitals, including all 12 Core Hospitals, all 33 Designated Hospitals, and 117 of 188 Cooperative Hospitals. The questionnaire asked how much time physicians and nonphysicians spent on administrative work for cancer genomic medicine. For every CGP test, 7.6 h of administrative work was needed. Physicians spent 2.7 h/patient, while nonphysicians spent 4.9 h/patient. Time spent preparing for molecular tumor boards, called Expert Panels, was the longest, followed by time spent participating in Expert Panels. Assuming an hourly wage of ¥24,000/h for physicians and ¥2800/h for nonphysicians, mean labor cost was ¥78,071/patient. On a monthly basis, more time was spent on administrative work at Core Hospitals compared with Designated Hospitals and Cooperative Hospitals (385 vs. 166 vs. 51 h/month, respectively, p < 0.001). Consequently, labor cost per month was higher at Core Hospitals than at Designated Hospitals and Cooperative Hospitals (¥3,951,854 vs. ¥1,687,167 vs. ¥487,279/month, respectively, p < 0.001). Completing a CGP test for a cancer patient in Japan is associated with significant labor at each hospital, especially at Core Hospitals. Streamlining the exchange of information and simplifying Expert Panels will likely alleviate this burden.
全面基因组分析(CGP)检测自 2019 年 6 月起在日本受到严格限制,并为超过 46000 名患者提供了检测服务。核心医院和指定医院设有分子肿瘤委员会,其组织工作比单纯参与要耗费更多时间。我们向政府指定的癌症基因组医学医院发放了一份调查问卷,其中包括所有 12 家核心医院、33 家指定医院和 188 家合作医院中的 117 家。问卷询问医生和非医生在癌症基因组医学方面的行政工作上花费了多少时间。每进行一次 CGP 检测,就需要花费 7.6 小时的行政工作时间。每位患者医生需要花费 2.7 小时,而非医生则需要花费 4.9 小时。为分子肿瘤委员会(称为专家小组)做准备所花费的时间最长,其次是参与专家小组的时间。假设医生每小时的工资为 24000 日元,非医生为 2800 日元,则平均劳动力成本为每位患者 78071 日元。就每月而言,核心医院的行政工作时间比指定医院和合作医院都要长(分别为 385、166 和 51 小时/月,p<0.001)。因此,核心医院的每月劳动力成本高于指定医院和合作医院(分别为 3951854、1687167 和 487279 日元/月,p<0.001)。在日本,为癌症患者完成一次 CGP 检测需要每家医院投入大量劳动力,尤其是核心医院。简化信息交流和简化专家小组可能会减轻这种负担。