Bungay H, Jensen A, Holt N
School of Allied and Public Health, Anglia Ruskin University, East Road, Cambridge CB1 1PT, UK.
Primary Healthcare, Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
Perspect Public Health. 2024 Nov;144(6):363-368. doi: 10.1177/17579139231170776. Epub 2023 May 12.
The positive outcomes of engaging in the arts are increasingly reported in the research literature, supporting the use of the arts to enhance individual and community health and wellbeing. However, little attention is given to the less positive aspects of arts engagement. In some countries, healthcare practitioners and link workers can refer service-users experiencing mental health issues to social interventions such as Arts on Prescription (AoP) programmes. This critical review identifies problematic issues across such social prescriptions and AoP, including failures in arts and health projects, participants' negative experiences, and an absence of ethical guidelines for arts and health practice. Furthermore, it is evident that there is a lack of awareness and knowledge within healthcare systems, leading to inappropriate referrals, failure to take account of individual preferences, and a lack of communication between the third sector and healthcare services. Significantly, it is also unclear who holds the health responsibility for AoP participants. This article raises more questions than it answers, but for AoP to be effectively embedded in healthcare practice, the issues highlighted need to be addressed in order to safeguard participants and support the effective implementation of programmes more widely.
研究文献中越来越多地报道了参与艺术活动的积极成果,这支持了利用艺术来促进个人和社区的健康与福祉。然而,人们很少关注艺术参与不太积极的方面。在一些国家,医疗从业者和联络人员可以将有心理健康问题的服务使用者转介到诸如“艺术处方”(AoP)项目等社会干预措施中。这篇批判性综述指出了此类社会处方和AoP项目中存在的问题,包括艺术与健康项目的失败、参与者的负面经历,以及缺乏艺术与健康实践的伦理准则。此外,很明显医疗系统内部缺乏认识和知识,导致转介不当、未能考虑个人偏好,以及第三部门与医疗服务之间缺乏沟通。值得注意的是,对于AoP参与者的健康责任由谁承担也不明确。本文提出的问题比给出的答案更多,但为了使AoP有效地融入医疗实践,需要解决所强调的问题,以保护参与者并更广泛地支持项目的有效实施。