Azizi Nahid, Pirsaheb Meghdad, Jaafarzadeh Neamat, Nabizadeh Nodehi Ramin
Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Environmental Health Engineering, Faculty of Health, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran.
Heliyon. 2023 Apr 22;9(5):e15664. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e15664. eCollection 2023 May.
The present study was carried out in the two phases of systematic review and experimental research. First, for the systematic review phase, Web of Science, Scopus, and PubMed as electronic databases were utilized to find research articles distributed up to March 5, 2021, related to the removal of microplastics by coagulation. In total, 104 publications were found, of which 14 were reviewed for deriving the variables and research design. Then, in the experimental phase, the experiment was carried out based on the variables derived from the systematic phase for three microplastic types (polyethylene, polystyrene, and polyamide) and five coagulants (polyaluminum chloride (PAC), ferric chloride (FeCl), aluminum chloride (AlCl), alum (Al(OH)) and aluminum sulfate (Al(SO))) in bench scale study. The differences between removal efficiencies in terms of type, shape, concentration, and size of microplastics within the looked into article was analyzed utilizing ANOVA or Kruskal-Wallis test (for parametric or nonparametric analysis, respectively). The results of experimental phase show that the removal efficiency of different microplastics was significantly different, and it was equal to 65, 22, and 12% on average for PA, PS, and PE, respectively. These averages are much lower than the average removal efficiency calculated in the reviewed articles (78 and 52% for PS and PE, respectively). The removal efficiency of microplastics types by coagulants was not significantly different. As a result, a coagulant that has the lowest dose can be selected as the most suitable coagulant, which is Al(OH) in this study.
本研究分系统评价和实验研究两个阶段进行。首先,在系统评价阶段,利用科学网、Scopus和PubMed这三个电子数据库查找截至2021年3月5日发表的与通过混凝去除微塑料相关的研究文章。总共找到104篇出版物,其中14篇经过评审以得出变量和研究设计。然后,在实验阶段,基于系统阶段得出的变量,针对三种微塑料类型(聚乙烯、聚苯乙烯和聚酰胺)和五种混凝剂(聚合氯化铝(PAC)、氯化铁(FeCl)、氯化铝(AlCl)、明矾(Al(OH))和硫酸铝(Al(SO)))进行了实验室规模的实验研究。利用方差分析或Kruskal-Wallis检验(分别用于参数分析或非参数分析)分析了所研究文章中微塑料在类型、形状、浓度和尺寸方面去除效率的差异。实验阶段的结果表明,不同微塑料的去除效率存在显著差异,PA、PS和PE的平均去除效率分别为65%、22%和12%。这些平均值远低于综述文章中计算的平均去除效率(PS和PE分别为78%和52%)。混凝剂对不同类型微塑料的去除效率没有显著差异。因此,可以选择剂量最低的混凝剂作为最合适的混凝剂,本研究中为Al(OH)。