Kelly Ryan M, Xing Yushan, Baker Steven, Waycott Jenny
School of Computing and Information Systems, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
School of Human Services and Social Work, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia.
JMIR Aging. 2023 Jun 12;6:e40953. doi: 10.2196/40953.
Lockdowns have been used to prevent the spread of transmissible illnesses such as influenza, norovirus, and COVID-19 in care homes. However, lockdowns deny care home residents supplemental care and the socioemotional enrichment that comes from seeing family members. Video calling has the potential to enable ongoing contact between residents and family members during lockdowns. However, video calls can be considered by some as a poor substitute for in-person visits. It is important to understand family members' experiences with video calling during lockdowns to ensure the effective use of this technology in the future.
This study aimed to understand how family members use video calls to communicate with relatives living in aged care during lockdowns. We focused on experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic, which involved extensive lockdowns in aged care homes.
We conducted semistructured interviews with 18 adults who had been using video calls with relatives living in aged care during pandemic lockdowns. The interviews focused on how participants had been using video calls, what benefits they gained from video-based interactions, and what challenges they encountered when using the technology. We analyzed the data using the 6-phase reflexive approach to thematic analysis by Braun and Clarke.
We developed 4 themes through our analysis. Theme 1 interprets video calling as a medium for the continuation of care during lockdowns. Using video calls, family members were able to provide social enrichment for residents and engaged in health monitoring to uphold residents' welfare. Theme 2 highlights how video calling extended care by supporting frequent contact, transmitting nonverbal cues that were essential for communication, and negating the need for face masks. Theme 3 interprets organizational issues such as the lack of technology and staff time as impediments to the continuation of familial care through video. Finally, theme 4 highlights the need for 2-way communication, interpreting residents' unfamiliarity with video calling and their health conditions as further barriers to the continuation of care.
This study suggests that, during restrictions arising from the COVID-19 pandemic, video calls became a medium for enabling family members to continue participating in the care of their relatives. The use of video calls to continue care illustrates their value for families during times of mandatory lockdown and supports the use of video to complement face-to-face visits at other times. However, better support is needed for video calling in aged care homes. This study also revealed a need for video calling systems that are designed for the aged care context.
封锁措施已被用于防止流感、诺如病毒和新冠病毒等传染性疾病在养老院传播。然而,封锁使养老院居民无法获得额外护理以及与家人见面所带来的社会情感丰富体验。视频通话有可能使居民和家人在封锁期间保持持续联系。然而,有些人可能认为视频通话是面对面探访的糟糕替代方式。了解家庭成员在封锁期间进行视频通话的体验,对于确保未来有效使用这项技术很重要。
本研究旨在了解家庭成员如何在封锁期间使用视频通话与住在老年护理机构的亲属进行沟通。我们关注的是新冠疫情期间的体验,在此期间养老院实施了广泛的封锁措施。
我们对18名成年人进行了半结构化访谈,这些人在疫情封锁期间一直与住在老年护理机构的亲属进行视频通话。访谈重点在于参与者如何使用视频通话、他们从基于视频的互动中获得了哪些益处,以及他们在使用该技术时遇到了哪些挑战。我们使用布劳恩和克拉克的六阶段主题分析反思方法对数据进行了分析。
通过分析,我们得出了4个主题。主题1将视频通话诠释为封锁期间延续护理的一种媒介。通过视频通话,家庭成员能够为居民提供社交丰富体验,并进行健康监测以维护居民的福祉。主题2强调视频通话如何通过支持频繁联系、传递沟通所需的非语言线索以及无需佩戴口罩来扩展护理。主题3将技术和工作人员时间不足等组织问题诠释为通过视频延续家庭护理的障碍。最后,主题4强调了双向沟通的必要性,将居民对视频通话的不熟悉及其健康状况诠释为延续护理的进一步障碍。
本研究表明,在新冠疫情导致的限制措施期间,视频通话成为使家庭成员能够继续参与亲属护理的一种媒介。使用视频通话延续护理说明了它们在强制封锁期间对家庭的价值,并支持在其他时间使用视频来补充面对面探访。然而,养老院的视频通话需要更好的支持。本研究还揭示了需要为老年护理环境设计的视频通话系统。