Intra-articular clodronate in patients with knee osteoarthritis non-responder to intra-articular hyaluronic acid - a case report series of 9 patients with 8-month follow-up.

BACKGROUND

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a common disease in the elderly people, inducing pain and functional limitations. Clodronate (CLO) a first generation non-nitrogen containing bisphosphonate has been purposed as a treatment of OA, being effective on pain, inflammation, bone marrow oedema, osteophytosis and cartilage regeneration. Intra-muscular routes of CLO showed efficacy in the treatment of Knee OA (KOA) and erosive OA of the hand. In KOA intraarticular CLO at low doses (0.5-2 mg) showed efficacy as well as hyaluronic acid (HA), being able to improve the effectiveness if associated to HA.

METHODS

Nine Consecutive patients (4 female, 5 male, mean age 78,22) with KOA at 2nd or 3rd degree following Kellgren-Lawrance scale, non responder to HA and unintended to surgery. They were treated with intraarticular CLO at the weekly dose of 20 mg, plus lidocaine 1% in 5 cc of saline solution for a route of 5 weekly infil-trations, followed by a second route of 5 intraarticular infiltrations 3 months after the first course. Visual analog score (VAS) pain and Tegner-Lysholm Score (TLS) were used to assess changes following CLO treatment.

RESULTS

Baseline pain was 6,77/10, reduced to 1,09 at day 150 (after second course) and to 2,3/10 at day 240. TLS at baseline was 56,7/100, improved to 96,7 at day 150 and to 84,1 at day 240. At day 240 only 2 out of 9 patients had a negative judgement of the treatment and decided to stop it, while 7 were satisfied and available to a further course. There was no increase of consumption of anti-inflammatory or analgesic drugs. A short time lasting pain after the injections was registered in all patients.

CONCLUSIONS

In a small cohort of patients affected by KOA, non responders to intraarticular HA a higher dose of intraarticular CLO in KOA showed good compliance, amelioration of pain and functionality.