Ritter M A, Meding J B
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1986 Jul(208):259-65.
One hundred sixty-nine posterior cruciate condylar knee arthroplasties were evaluated for investigation of the effect of anterior displacement on instability and interface radiolucency in total knee arthroplasty. All knees were followed for at least one year, and 37 knees were followed for at least three years. The status of the anterior cruciate ligament at surgery was first compared to the postoperative, six-month, one-year, and three-year anterior drawer sign. A correlation coefficient was computed to test for the existence of a relation between these two variables. A chi-square test for statistical significance was used to compare the overall anterior drawer results with time and the anterior drawer sign at each follow-up evaluation with pain and radiolucent zones between cement and bone. For further evaluation of the effect of anterior stability on radiolucent zones, the authors analyzed the records of all their posterior cruciate condylar total knee arthroplasties over a seven-year period (average follow-up period, 2.5 years). Anterior stability over time was independent of the status of the anterior cruciate at surgery, and the presence or absence of an anterior cruciate ligament at surgery did not affect anterior stability over time. Furthermore, cutting of the anterior cruciate did not change anterior stability over time. Anterior instability proved to be statistically less at six months than at surgery and did not become worse with time. Neither anterior instability nor the preoperative state of the anterior cruciate ligament affects pain and interface radiolucency between cement and bone.
对169例后交叉髁膝关节置换术进行评估,以研究全膝关节置换术中前移位对不稳定和界面透亮线的影响。所有膝关节均随访至少1年,37例膝关节随访至少3年。首先将手术时前交叉韧带的状态与术后6个月、1年和3年时的前抽屉试验结果进行比较。计算相关系数以检验这两个变量之间关系的存在性。采用卡方检验统计显著性,将总体前抽屉试验结果随时间的变化以及每次随访评估时的前抽屉试验结果与疼痛及骨水泥与骨之间的透亮区进行比较。为进一步评估前稳定性对透亮区的影响,作者分析了他们在7年期间(平均随访期2.5年)所有后交叉髁全膝关节置换术的记录。随着时间推移,前稳定性与手术时前交叉韧带的状态无关,手术时前交叉韧带的存在与否并不影响随时间的前稳定性。此外,切断前交叉韧带并不会改变随时间的前稳定性。事实证明,6个月时的前不稳定在统计学上低于手术时,且不会随时间恶化。前不稳定和术前前交叉韧带状态均不影响骨水泥与骨之间的疼痛和界面透亮线。