State Key Laboratory of Herbage Improvement and Grassland Agro-Ecosystems, College of Ecology, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, China.
Health and Environmental Sciences, Xi'an Jiaotong-Liverpool University, Suzhou, China.
J Anim Ecol. 2023 Jul;92(7):1345-1356. doi: 10.1111/1365-2656.13938. Epub 2023 May 21.
Over the last 40 years, a burrowing mammal eradication policy has been prevalent on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau (QTP). This policy is based on similar burrowing mammal eradication programs in other areas and is justified on the assumptions that burrowing mammals compete with livestock for forage and contribute to grassland degradation. However, there is no clear theoretical or experimental evidence supporting these assumptions. This paper synthesizes the ecological functioning of small burrowing mammals in natural grasslands and discusses the irrationality and consequences of burrowing mammal eradication for sustainable livestock grazing and grassland degradation. Past burrowing mammal eradication efforts have failed because increased food availability for the remaining rodents and reduced predator populations led to rapid population rebounds. Herbivores differ in diet, and there is clear evidence that burrowing mammals, especially plateau zokors Myospalax baileyi, have a different diet than livestock. In QTP meadows, burrowing mammal eradication induces a shift towards plant communities with fewer species preferred by livestock and more species preferred by burrowing mammals. Thus, eradicating burrowing mammals has the opposite effect, a reduction in livestock preferred vegetation. We suggest that the policy of poisoning burrowing mammals needs to be reconsidered and revoked as soon as possible. We argue that incorporating density-dependent factors such as predation and food availability are essential for maintaining a low burrowing mammal density. For degraded grasslands, we suggest that the optimal sustainable approach is to decrease the intensity of livestock grazing. Lower grazing induces changes in vegetation structure and plant species composition that increases predation on burrowing mammals and decreases the abundance of plants preferred by burrowing mammals. Such a nature-based grassland management system maintains the density of burrowing mammals at a low stable density while minimizing human management and interventions.
在过去的 40 年里,青藏高原(QTP)上一直流行着一种消灭穴居哺乳动物的政策。该政策基于其他地区类似的穴居哺乳动物消灭计划,并假设穴居哺乳动物与牲畜争夺饲料,并导致草原退化。然而,没有明确的理论或实验证据支持这些假设。本文综合了天然草原中小型穴居哺乳动物的生态功能,并讨论了穴居哺乳动物消灭对可持续牲畜放牧和草原退化的不合理性和后果。过去的穴居哺乳动物消灭努力失败了,因为剩余啮齿动物的食物供应增加和捕食者数量减少导致了种群的快速反弹。食草动物的饮食不同,有明确的证据表明,穴居哺乳动物,特别是高原鼢鼠 Myospalax baileyi,与牲畜的饮食不同。在 QTP 草地中,穴居哺乳动物的消灭导致了植物群落向牲畜更喜欢的物种减少和穴居哺乳动物更喜欢的物种增加的转变。因此,消灭穴居哺乳动物的效果相反,会减少牲畜喜欢的植被。我们建议需要重新考虑并尽快撤销消灭穴居哺乳动物的政策。我们认为,纳入捕食和食物供应等密度依赖性因素对于维持低穴居哺乳动物密度是至关重要的。对于退化的草原,我们建议最佳的可持续方法是降低牲畜放牧强度。较低的放牧会引起植被结构和植物物种组成的变化,增加对穴居哺乳动物的捕食,并减少穴居哺乳动物喜欢的植物的丰度。这种基于自然的草原管理系统可以将穴居哺乳动物的密度维持在低而稳定的水平,同时最大限度地减少人类管理和干预。