APHP, Hôpital Bichat Claude Bernard, Service de Médecine Interne DMU Victoire Paris, Paris, France.
Université Paris-Cité, Paris, France.
PLoS One. 2023 May 22;18(5):e0285894. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0285894. eCollection 2023.
Conflict of interests (COIs) adversely affect the integrity of science and public health. The role of medical schools in the teaching and management of COIs has been highlighted by the publication of an annual evaluation of American medical schools based on their COIs policies by the American Medical Student Association (AMSA). A deontological charter was adopted by French medical schools in 2018 but its impact on COI comprehension by students and its effects on COI prevention were not evaluated.
A 10-item direct survey was conducted among about 1000 students in Paris-Cité University in order to investigate the respect of the charter regarding COIs both in the medical school and in affiliated teaching hospitals.
Cumulative results show a satisfying respect of prevention policies regarding COIs in the medical school and hospitals despite the fact that the existence of the charter and its major aspects were insufficiently known. Disclosure of COIs by teachers was insufficient.
This first direct study among students shows better results than expected according to current non-academic surveys. Moreover, this study demonstrates the feasibility of this kind of survey whose repetition should be an appropriate tool to improve the implementation of the charter within medical schools and teaching hospitals, in particular mandatory disclosure of COIs by teachers.
利益冲突(COIs)会对科学和公共卫生的完整性产生不利影响。美国医学学生协会(AMSA)根据其 COIs 政策对美国医学院进行年度评估,这一事件凸显了医学院在 COIs 教学和管理中的作用。2018 年,法国医学院通过了一项职业道德宪章,但尚未对其对学生对 COIs 的理解的影响及其对 COI 预防的效果进行评估。
在巴黎-西岱大学对大约 1000 名学生进行了 10 项直接调查,以调查宪章在医学院及其附属教学医院中对 COIs 的遵守情况。
累积结果表明,尽管宪章及其主要方面知之甚少,但医学院和医院在 COIs 预防政策方面的遵守情况令人满意。教师披露 COIs 的情况不足。
这是对学生进行的第一项直接研究,结果好于当前非学术调查的预期。此外,这项研究证明了这种调查的可行性,重复进行此类调查应是改善医学院和教学医院内宪章执行情况的适当工具,特别是教师强制性披露 COIs。