Department of Behavioral and Cognitive Biology, University of Vienna, University Biology Building, Djerassiplatz 1, 1030, Vienna, Austria.
Social Cognition Center, University of Cologne, Faculty of Human Sciences, Cologne, Germany.
Anim Cogn. 2023 Jul;26(4):1353-1368. doi: 10.1007/s10071-023-01785-y. Epub 2023 May 23.
Comparing oneself to others is a key process in humans that allows individuals to gauge their performances and abilities and thus develop and calibrate their self-image. Little is known about its evolutionary foundations. A key feature of social comparison is the sensitivity to other individuals' performance. Recent studies on primates produced equivocal results, leading us to distinguish between a 'strong' variant of the social comparison hypothesis formulated for humans and a 'weak' variant found in non-human primates that would comprise some elements of human social comparison. Here, we focus on corvids that are distantly related to primates and renowned for their socio-cognitive skills. We were interested in whether crows' task performances were influenced (i) by the presence of a conspecific co-actor performing the same discrimination task and (ii) by the simulated acoustic cues of a putative co-actor performing better or worse than themselves. Crows reached a learning criterion quicker when tested simultaneously as compared to when tested alone, indicating a facilitating effect of social context. The performance of a putative co-actor influenced their performance: crows were better at discriminating familiar images when their co-actor was better than they were. Standard extremity (how pronounced the difference was between the performance of the subject and that of the co-actor), and category membership (affiliation status and sex), of the putative co-actors had no effect on their performance. Our findings are in line with the 'weak' variant of social comparison and indicate that elements of human social comparison can be found outside of primates.
将自己与他人进行比较是人类的一个关键过程,它使个体能够衡量自己的表现和能力,从而发展和调整自我形象。然而,人们对其进化基础知之甚少。社会比较的一个关键特征是对他人表现的敏感性。最近对灵长类动物的研究得出了相互矛盾的结果,这促使我们区分出适用于人类的“强”变体和在非人类灵长类动物中发现的“弱”变体,后者包含了人类社会比较的一些元素。在这里,我们关注的是与灵长类动物关系较远但以社会认知技能而闻名的鸦科鸟类。我们感兴趣的是,乌鸦的任务表现是否会受到以下因素的影响:(i) 存在同物种的共同执行者执行相同的辨别任务,以及 (ii) 存在假设的共同执行者表现优于或劣于自己的模拟声音线索。与单独测试相比,乌鸦在同时测试时更快地达到学习标准,这表明社会环境具有促进作用。假设的共同执行者的表现会影响它们的表现:当它们的共同执行者比它们更好时,乌鸦在辨别熟悉的图像时表现更好。标准极端(主体和共同执行者之间的表现差异有多大)和类别成员(隶属关系和性别)对共同执行者的表现没有影响。我们的发现与社会比较的“弱”变体一致,表明人类社会比较的某些元素可以在灵长类动物之外找到。