Flentje Markus, Eismann Hendrik, Schwill Simon, Forstner Daniel, Kranke Peter
Klinik für Anästhesiologie und Intensivmedizin, Medizinische Hochschule Hannover, Carl-Neuberg-Str. 1, 30625, Hannover, Deutschland.
Abteilung Allgemeinmedizin und Versorgungsforschung, Universitätsklinikum Heidelberg, Im Neuenheimer Feld 130.3, 69120, Heidelberg, Deutschland.
Anaesthesiologie. 2023 Jun;72(6):399-407. doi: 10.1007/s00101-023-01283-3. Epub 2023 May 24.
Anesthesiologic expertise is used at various points in the delivery room. The natural turnover of professionals requires continuous education and training for patient care. In a first survey among consultants and trainees, the desire for a delivery room-specific anesthesiologic curriculum has emerged. In order to enable a curriculum with decreasing supervision, a competence-oriented catalogue is used in many medical fields. The gain in competence develops gradually. The participation of practitioners should be obligatory to avoid a differentiation between theory and practice. The structural framework of curriculum development by Kern et al. provides the learning objective analysis after further evaluation. In the sense of specific learning objective definition, the present study aims to describe the competences for anesthetists in the delivery room.
An expert group (active in the anesthesiology delivery room environment) developed a set of items via a two-step online Delphi survey. The experts were recruited from the German Society for Anesthesiology and Intensive Care Medicine (DGAI). We evaluated the resulting parameters for relevance and validity in a larger collective. Lastly, we used factorial analyses to identify factors that could be used to group items into relevant scales. In total, 201 participants took part in the final validation survey.
During the prioritization process of Delphi analyses, competencies such as neonatal care were not followed up. Not all items developed are exclusively delivery room-related, such as managing a difficult airway. Other items are specific to the environment of obstetrics. One example is integration of spinal anesthesia into the obstetric context. Some items are exclusively related to the delivery room, such as in-house standards of care in obstetrics as a basic skill. After validation, a competence catalogue with 8 scales with a total of 44 competence items resulted (Kayser-Meyer-Olkin criterion 0.88).
A catalogue of relevant learning objectives for anesthetists in training could be developed. It specifies the generally required content of anesthesiologic training in Germany. Specific patient groups, such as patients with congenital heart defects, are not mapped. Competencies that could also be learned outside the delivery room, should be learned before the rotation. This enables the focus on the delivery room items, especially for those to be trained who do not work in a hospital with obstetrics. The catalogue needs to be revised for completeness for its own working environment. Particularly in hospitals that do not have a pediatrician available, neonatal care becomes significant. Didactic methods, such as entrustable professional activities, have to be tested and evaluated. These enable competence-based learning with decreasing supervision and reflect the reality in hospitals. As not every clinic can provide the necessary resources for this a nationwide provision of documents would be helpful.
产房工作的各个环节都需要麻醉专业知识。专业人员的自然更替要求持续开展继续教育和培训,以保障患者护理质量。在对顾问和实习生的首次调查中,已出现对特定于产房的麻醉学课程的需求。为了制定一个减少监督的课程,许多医学领域都采用了以能力为导向的目录。能力的提升是逐步实现的。从业者必须参与其中,以避免理论与实践脱节。Kern等人提出的课程开发结构框架在进一步评估后提供了学习目标分析。从明确具体学习目标的角度出发,本研究旨在描述产房麻醉医生所需的能力。
一个活跃于产房麻醉环境的专家小组通过两步在线德尔菲调查制定了一组项目。专家们来自德国麻醉与重症医学学会(DGAI)。我们在更大的群体中评估了所得参数的相关性和有效性。最后,我们使用因子分析来确定可用于将项目分组到相关量表中的因素。共有201名参与者参加了最终的验证调查。
在德尔菲分析的优先排序过程中,诸如新生儿护理等能力未得到跟进。并非所有制定的项目都仅与产房相关,例如处理困难气道。其他项目则特定于产科环境。一个例子是将脊髓麻醉融入产科情况。有些项目仅与产房相关,例如产科内部护理标准作为一项基本技能。验证后,形成了一个包含8个量表、共44项能力项目的能力目录(Kayser-Meyer-Olkin标准为0.88)。
可以制定一份针对实习麻醉医生的相关学习目标目录。它明确了德国麻醉学培训通常所需的内容。特定患者群体,如先天性心脏病患者,未被涵盖。那些在产房外也能学到的能力,应在轮转前学习。这使得能够专注于产房相关项目,特别是对于那些不在设有产科的医院工作的待培训人员。该目录需要根据自身工作环境进行修订以确保完整性。特别是在没有儿科医生的医院,新生儿护理变得尤为重要。必须测试和评估诸如可托付专业活动等教学方法。这些方法能够实现基于能力的学习且监督逐渐减少,并反映医院的实际情况。由于并非每个诊所都能为此提供必要资源,全国范围内提供相关文件将有所帮助。