Division for Applied Justice Research, RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA.
Division for Applied Justice Research, RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA.
Drug Alcohol Depend. 2023 Jul 1;248:109916. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2023.109916. Epub 2023 May 9.
The United States continues to experience unprecedented rates of overdose mortality. Addressing the overdose epidemic has been challenging for policy makers given the lack of effectiveness of existing drug control policy measures. More recently, the implementation of harm reduction-based policies such as Good Samaritan Laws has led to increasing scholarly attention aimed at evaluating their effectiveness at reducing the likelihood of criminal justice-related sanctions for individuals following an overdose incident. The results of these studies, however, have been mixed.
This study utilizes data from a nationally representative survey of law enforcement agencies designed to provide national information on services, policies, practices, operations, and resources of law enforcement drug response around overdoses to assess whether state Good Samaritan Laws reduce the likelihood of overdose victims being cited or being jailed following an overdose incident.
In general, findings indicate that although most agencies reported that overdose victims were not incarcerated or cited following an overdose incident, that this did not vary by whether agencies were in a state that had a GSL arrest protection for possession of controlled substances.
GSLs are often written in complex and confusing language that officers and people who use drugs do not fully understand, which may deter their being used for their intended purpose. Although GSLs are well-intentioned, these findings highlight the need for training and education for law enforcement and people who use drugs around the scope of these laws.
美国继续经历着前所未有的过量死亡率。由于现有药物控制政策措施缺乏有效性,政策制定者在解决过量流行问题上面临挑战。最近,实施基于减少伤害的政策,如“好撒玛利亚人法”,导致越来越多的学者关注这些政策在减少过量事件后个人遭受刑事司法制裁的可能性方面的有效性。然而,这些研究的结果喜忧参半。
本研究利用了一项针对执法机构的全国代表性调查的数据,旨在提供关于执法机构对过量事件的服务、政策、实践、运作和资源的全国信息,以评估州“好撒玛利亚人法”是否降低了过量受害者在过量事件后被引用或监禁的可能性。
总的来说,研究结果表明,尽管大多数机构报告说,过量受害者在过量事件后没有被监禁或被引用,但这与机构所在州是否有对持有受控物质的逮捕保护的 GSL 无关。
GSL 通常以复杂和令人困惑的语言书写,执法人员和吸毒者并不完全理解,这可能会阻止它们被用于预期的目的。虽然 GSL 是出于好意,但这些发现强调了需要对执法人员和吸毒者进行有关这些法律范围的培训和教育。