Nenko Ilona, Kopeć-Godlewska Katarzyna, Towner Mary C, Klein Laura D, Micek Agnieszka
Department of Environmental Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland.
Laboratory of Fundamental Obstetric Care, Faculty of Health Sciences, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Krakow, Poland.
Evol Med Public Health. 2023 May 14;11(1):139-148. doi: 10.1093/emph/eoad013. eCollection 2023.
Birth is a critical event in women's lives. Since humans have evolved to give birth in the context of social support, not having it in modern settings might lead to more complications during birth. Our aim was to model how emotional factors and medical interventions related to birth outcomes in hospital settings in Poland, where c-section rates have doubled in the last decade.
We analysed data from 2363 low-risk primiparous women who went into labor with the intention of giving birth vaginally. We used a model comparison approach to examine the relationship between emotional and medical variables and birth outcome (vaginal or c-section), including sociodemographic control variables in all models.
A model with emotional factors better explained the data than a control model (Δ = 470.8); women with continuous personal support during labor had lower odds of a c-section compared to those attended by hospital staff only (OR = 0.12, 95% CI = 0.09 - 0.16). A model that included medical interventions also better explained the data than a control model (Δ = 133.6); women given epidurals, in particular, had increased odds of a c-section over those who were not (OR = 3.55, 95% CI = 2.95 - 4.27). The best model included variables for both the level of personal support and the use of epidural (Δ = 598.0).
Continuous personal support during childbirth may be an evolutionarily informed strategy for reducing complications, including one of the most common obstetrical complications in modern hospital settings, the c-section.
分娩是女性生命中的关键事件。由于人类在社会支持的环境中进化到分娩,在现代环境中缺乏这种支持可能会导致分娩期间出现更多并发症。我们的目的是模拟在波兰医院环境中,情绪因素和医疗干预与分娩结果之间的关系,在波兰,剖宫产率在过去十年中翻了一番。
我们分析了2363名低风险初产妇的数据,她们分娩时打算顺产。我们采用模型比较方法来检验情绪和医疗变量与分娩结果(顺产或剖宫产)之间的关系,所有模型中均纳入社会人口统计学控制变量。
一个包含情绪因素的模型比一个对照模型能更好地解释数据(Δ = 470.8);与仅由医院工作人员照料的女性相比,分娩期间获得持续个人支持的女性剖宫产几率更低(比值比 = 0.12,95%置信区间 = 0.09 - 0.16)。一个包含医疗干预的模型也比对照模型能更好地解释数据(Δ = 133.6);特别是,接受硬膜外麻醉的女性比未接受硬膜外麻醉的女性剖宫产几率增加(比值比 = 3.55,95%置信区间 = 2.95 - 4.27)。最佳模型同时纳入了个人支持水平和硬膜外麻醉使用情况的变量(Δ = 598.0)。
分娩期间持续的个人支持可能是一种基于进化的减少并发症的策略,包括现代医院环境中最常见的产科并发症之一,剖宫产。