School of Pharmacy, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
School of Clinical Sciences, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
Basic Clin Pharmacol Toxicol. 2024 Jan;134(1):15-27. doi: 10.1111/bcpt.13907. Epub 2023 Jun 20.
Deprescribing decision making in older adults with limited life expectancy is often challenging for clinicians. We aimed to develop and validate a Deprescribing Tool for Older People with Limited-life Expectancy (De-TOPPLE). Modified Delphi technique was used to gain experts' consensus on the tool and further develop using their feedback. Experts [Round-1 (n = 13), Round-2 (n = 7)] had clinical and/or research background on geriatric medicine, geriatrics, family medicine or pharmacotherapy. Round-1 consensus was achieved on approach taken by the tool to evaluate risk and benefit; distinguishing medications as preventive, symptom control or dual-purpose; referring to established deprescribing process; stepwise approach to deprescribing; and the overall concept. Common feedback was to reflect upon harm-benefit analysis, distinguish medication types earlier, qualify adverse events, use time-to-benefit (TTB), prioritise symptom relief, monitor post-deprescribing, include shared decision making and define terms for clinical familiarisation. After tool update, Round-2 consensus was achieved on usability in clinical setting, flexibility of implicit judgement, ceasing preventive medication with inadequate TTB, ceasing symptom control medication with inadequate symptom relief, ceasing dual-purpose medication (DPM) with inadequate TTB and symptom relief, and continuing DPM with adequate TTB and symptom relief. De-TOPPLE version 1 was developed and validated through two rounds of the Delphi process. Clinical use of the tool needs final validation following the addition of contextual statements to the tool.
为预期寿命有限的老年人做出撤药决策对临床医生来说往往具有挑战性。我们旨在开发和验证一个用于预期寿命有限的老年人的撤药工具(De-TOPPLE)。采用改良 Delphi 技术来征求专家对该工具的共识,并根据他们的反馈意见进一步开发。专家[第 1 轮(n=13),第 2 轮(n=7)]在老年医学、老年病学、家庭医学或药物治疗方面具有临床和/或研究背景。第 1 轮共识达成于工具评估风险和获益的方法;将药物区分预防、症状控制或双重用途;参考既定的撤药流程;逐步撤药;以及整体概念。常见的反馈意见是对危害-效益分析进行反思,更早地区分药物类型,确定不良事件,使用获益时间(TTB),优先考虑症状缓解,监测撤药后情况,纳入共同决策,并为临床熟悉定义术语。在更新工具后,第 2 轮共识达成于临床环境中的可用性、隐含判断的灵活性、TTB 不足的预防用药的停止、症状缓解不足的症状控制药物的停止、TTB 和症状缓解不足的双重用途药物(DPM)的停止,以及 TTB 和症状缓解足够的 DPM 的继续使用。De-TOPPLE 版本 1 通过两轮 Delphi 过程开发和验证。该工具的临床应用需要在工具中添加上下文语句后进行最终验证。