Pregnancy Loss Research Group, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
INFANT Research Centre, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Health Expect. 2023 Aug;26(4):1768-1782. doi: 10.1111/hex.13791. Epub 2023 Jun 9.
Maternity services underwent much change during the COVID-19 pandemic. Research on the impact on miscarriage care and experiences during this time is sparse. Within a national evaluation of recurrent miscarriage care, we qualitatively explored stakeholder views and experiences of recurrent miscarriage services in Ireland. This study describes the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on those experiences and perceptions of care.
People with professional and lived experience of recurrent miscarriage and service engagement were actively involved in this qualitative study from idea generation to analysis and reporting. We recruited women and men with two or more consecutive first-trimester miscarriages, and people involved in the management/delivery of recurrent miscarriage services and supports. We used purposive sampling to ensure that perspectives across disciplinary or lived experience, geographical, and health service administrative areas, were included. We conducted semi-structured interviews, virtually all due to COVID-19 restrictions, between June 2020 and February 2021. These were audio-recorded, and data were transcribed, and subsequently analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis.
We interviewed 42 service providers and 13 women and 7 men with experience of recurrent miscarriage. We actively generated two central themes during data analysis. The first-'Disconnected'-describes how many women navigated miscarriage diagnosis and management and care in subsequent pregnancies alone; many felt that this resulted in increased trauma. At the same time, men struggled with not being present to support their partners and described feeling disconnected. The second theme highlighted 'The perceived dispensability of recurrent miscarriage services and supports'. Some service providers felt that service reduction and redeployment demonstrated a lack of value in the service. Virtual clinics facilitated access to services, but a preference for in-person care was highlighted.
Our analysis provides rich insights into the significant impacts that the COVID-19 pandemic has had on the way recurrent miscarriage care is provided and experienced, with important implications for early pregnancy, miscarriage and recurrent miscarriage care. Services have undergone significant changes and, while these may be temporary, how services should be delivered in the future requires consideration, particularly given the deficits in care and care experiences highlighted prepandemic.
Members of the multidisciplinary RE:CURRENT Project Research Advisory Group (including four parent advocates, two of whom are co-authors on this article) were actively involved throughout the study, including the generation of topic guides and the refining of themes.
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,产妇服务发生了很大变化。关于流产护理的影响以及在此期间的经验的研究很少。在对复发性流产护理的全国性评估中,我们从想法生成到分析和报告,都积极探索了利益相关者对爱尔兰复发性流产服务的看法和经验。本研究描述了 COVID-19 大流行对这些经验和护理认知的影响。
具有复发性流产专业和生活经验以及服务参与的人员从想法生成到分析和报告,积极参与了这项定性研究。我们招募了经历过两次或两次以上连续早期流产的女性和男性,以及参与复发性流产服务和支持管理/提供的人员。我们使用目的性抽样,以确保包括不同学科或生活经验、地理和卫生服务行政区域的观点。我们在 2020 年 6 月至 2021 年 2 月期间进行了半结构化访谈,这都是由于 COVID-19 限制。访谈内容被录音,数据被转录,随后使用反思性主题分析进行分析。
我们采访了 42 名服务提供者和 13 名经历过复发性流产的女性和 7 名男性。在数据分析过程中,我们积极生成了两个中心主题。第一个主题是“脱节”,描述了许多女性如何独自应对流产诊断和管理以及后续妊娠的护理;许多人认为这导致了更多的创伤。与此同时,男性难以在伴侣身边提供支持,并表示感到脱节。第二个主题强调了“复发性流产服务和支持的可被替代性感知”。一些服务提供者认为服务的减少和重新部署表明该服务缺乏价值。虚拟诊所方便了对服务的获取,但也突出了对面对面护理的偏好。
我们的分析深入了解了 COVID-19 大流行对复发性流产护理方式和体验的重大影响,对早期妊娠、流产和复发性流产护理具有重要意义。服务发生了重大变化,虽然这些变化可能是暂时的,但未来如何提供服务需要考虑,特别是考虑到大流行前已经凸显的护理和护理体验方面的不足。
多学科 RE:CURRENT 项目研究咨询小组的成员(包括四位家长倡导者,其中两位是本文的共同作者)在整个研究过程中都积极参与,包括主题指南的制定和主题的细化。