Texas A&M University Irma Lerma Rangel School of Pharmacy, Kingsville, TX 78363, USA.
Texas A&M University Irma Lerma Rangel School of Pharmacy, Kingsville, TX 78363, USA.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2023 Nov;87(11):100543. doi: 10.1016/j.ajpe.2023.100543. Epub 2023 Jun 16.
To determine how underrepresented minority (URM) student pharmacists' intersectionality affects professional identity formation early in their academic career.
A qualitative study was undertaken. All students from Classes 2022 through 2025 at Texas A&M University School of Pharmacy were required to engage in reflection on a personal statement of philosophy of practice early in their first year of pharmacy as part of the structured longitudinal co-curricular course requirement. Statements of the URM students who referenced their intersecting identities were selected for deductive analysis per Bingham and Witkowsky and inductive analysis using Lincoln and Guba's approach to content analysis.
Of the 221 URM student pharmacists within the 4 cohorts who submitted a statement, 38 statements (92% Hispanic students) met the inclusion criteria. Student hometowns and the identity domains of the individual, relational, and collective were selected a priori for the deductive analysis. Students most often referenced individual identity characteristics that fit under the Principles I, IV, V, and VII of the Code of Ethics for Pharmacists. Three themes emerged from the inductive analysis: (1) defining experiences and resulting realizations, (2) motivating forces, and (3) aspirations as a pharmacist. A working hypothesis was developed.
The URM students' intersecting identities (race, ethnicity, socioeconomic class, and belonging to an underserved community) influenced their early professional identity formation. The desire to bring about racial uplift was observed among the Hispanic students as early in their P1 year through the School's required co-curricular reflection. Such reflective practice serves as an effective vehicle for the students to recognize their intersecting identities that impact their professional identity.
确定少数民族裔(URM)药学学生的交叉性如何影响他们在学术生涯早期的专业身份形成。
进行了一项定性研究。德克萨斯 A&M 大学药学院 2022 年至 2025 年的所有学生都被要求在药学第一年的早期就实践哲学的个人陈述进行反思,这是结构化纵向合作课程要求的一部分。选择了引用其交叉身份的 URM 学生的陈述,以便按照 Bingham 和 Witkowsky 的方法进行演绎分析,并按照 Lincoln 和 Guba 的方法进行内容分析的归纳分析。
在 4 个队列中的 221 名 URM 药学学生中,有 221 名提交了一份陈述,其中 38 份陈述(92%的西班牙裔学生)符合纳入标准。学生的家乡和个人、关系和集体的身份领域是预先选择用于演绎分析的。学生最常引用符合《药师职业道德准则》原则 I、IV、V 和 VII 的个人身份特征。从归纳分析中出现了三个主题:(1)定义经验和由此产生的认识,(2)动机,以及(3)作为药剂师的愿望。提出了一个工作假设。
URM 学生的交叉身份(种族、族裔、社会经济地位和属于服务不足的社区)影响了他们早期的专业身份形成。通过学校要求的合作课程反思,西班牙裔学生在 P1 年就表现出了提升种族的愿望。这种反思实践是学生认识到影响其专业身份的交叉身份的有效手段。