Extensio et Progressio, Collonge-Bellerive, Switzerland.
Department of Medical Education and Informatics, Hacettepe University School of Medicine, Sıhhiye, Ankara, Türkiye.
Teach Learn Med. 2024 Aug-Sep;36(4):488-503. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2023.2226659. Epub 2023 Jun 22.
: As the first stage of a large-scale educational design research (EDR) study focused on the complex problem of providing authentic experiential "hands-on, minds-in" learning opportunities online during a pandemic or other exigency, we conducted a literature review and we interviewed Turkish academic staff and students about their experiences during the first year of the COVID-19 Pandemic. We interviewed faculty members, faculty members of medical education departments, and medical students from both public and private medical schools in Türkiye between October 1 and December 31, 2020. Working in pairs, we analyzed the transcripts of 49 interviews using open qualitative coding methods with satisfactory levels of coefficients of agreement. We defined six major themes from the qualitative analysis: 1) Fear and concern were the most common reactions when first encountering the pandemic; 2) Teaching methods during the pandemic were primarily unidirectional from faculty to students. This largely one way transmission of information occurred both synchronously and asynchronously; 3) Technological support during the pandemic shutdowns was found to be challenging for both faculties and students; 4) Evaluation of learning during the pandemic was opportunistic and had questionable rigor; 5) Healthy communication was valued by both faculty and students using an array of different tools including social media; and 6) The pandemic had both negative and positive impacts on the educational processes experienced by students and provided by faculty and resulted in recommendations for new approaches to teaching and learning in the future. Medical students were primarily concerned about the susceptibility to COVID-19 of themselves and others, and how the pandemic would affect their progress toward completing their studies. Faculty were primarily concerned about the capacity of online learning to provide clinical learning opportunities and the difficulties of assessing student clinical skills using online modalities. Medical education specialists were primarily concerned about the quality of educational opportunities offered online. Our findings were similar to other studies conducted in the USA, China, United Kingdom, and other countries. However, the interviews revealed interest among faculty and medical education specialists for further investigation of experiential or active learning models that could be applied in medical education regardless of whether the delivery mode is face-to-face, online, or most likely, blended. In the next stage of our larger scale EDR study, we will design and construct prototype learning environments that incorporate experiential, active, and authentic learning design principles.
作为一项大型教育设计研究(EDR)的第一阶段,该研究专注于在大流行或其他紧急情况下在线提供真实体验式“动手、动脑”学习机会这一复杂问题,我们进行了文献回顾,并就大流行第一年的经历采访了土耳其的学术人员和学生。我们采访了土耳其公共和私立医学院的教师、医学教育部门的教师和医学生,采访时间为 2020 年 10 月 1 日至 12 月 31 日。我们以两人一组的方式,使用开放式定性编码方法对 49 次访谈的记录进行了分析,并且一致性系数达到了令人满意的水平。我们从定性分析中定义了六个主要主题:1)当首次遇到大流行时,恐惧和担忧是最常见的反应;2)大流行期间的教学方法主要是单向的,即从教师到学生。这种信息的单向传递既可以同步进行,也可以异步进行;3)大流行停课时的技术支持对教师和学生来说都具有挑战性;4)大流行期间的学习评估是机会主义的,并且严谨性值得怀疑;5)教师和学生都非常重视健康沟通,并使用各种不同的工具,包括社交媒体;6)大流行对学生和教师所经历的教育过程产生了负面影响和积极影响,并为未来的教学和学习提出了新方法的建议。医学生主要担心自己和他人对 COVID-19 的易感性,以及大流行将如何影响他们完成学业的进度。教师主要担心在线学习能否提供临床学习机会,以及使用在线模式评估学生临床技能的困难。医学教育专家主要关注在线提供的教育机会的质量。我们的研究结果与在美国、中国、英国和其他国家进行的其他研究相似。然而,访谈揭示了教师和医学教育专家对进一步研究体验式或主动学习模式的兴趣,这些模式可以应用于医学教育,无论教学模式是面对面、在线还是混合式。在我们更大规模的 EDR 研究的下一阶段,我们将设计和构建包含体验式、主动和真实学习设计原则的原型学习环境。