Ballester Benoit, Pilliol Virginie, Allaerd Perrine, Jacquot Bruno, Guivarc'h Maud
Pôle d'Odontologie, Assistance Publique des Hôpitaux de Marseille, Marseille, France.
Aix Marseille Univ, INSERM, IRD, SESSTIM, Sciences Economiques & Sociales de la Santé & Traitement de l'Information Médicale, ISSPAM, Marseille, France.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2024 Feb;28(1):161-169. doi: 10.1111/eje.12933. Epub 2023 Jun 22.
Teaching caries lesion management with operative care requires tooth models with highly realistic anatomical detail and caries lesions that can be assessed using ICDAS. This study aimed to develop and evaluate a new 3D-printed teeth model for ICDAS assessment and caries removal for pre-clinical hands-on education.
Printable tooth with different layers for enamel, dentin and carious lesions was designed and tested by 31 dental students. They were asked to visually and radiologically assess the ICDAS severity of the simulated carious lesions, establish the therapeutic strategy according to CariesCare 4D, and perform a qualitative assessment of the models based on five-point Likert scale items.
Concerning carious lesions, the texture was realistic, and the shade was adequate for 94% and 97% of the participants. Ninety per cent of the participants found the model adequate to perform an ICDAS visual assessment. Seventy-four per cent of the students found the hardness adequate. Concerning the difference in shade and the noticeable hardness difference between enamel and dentin, participants have mixed agreement with a proportion of 61% and 55%, respectively. All the participants agreed these 3D-printed models provide a good caries simulation, are suitable for hands-on operative dentistry courses, and that learning outcomes better than the standard model.
The present work shows that rapid prototyping paves the way for customized educational models capable of supporting operative but also preoperative skills. 3D printing opens up new opportunities by reducing the gap between pre-clinical training and clinical reality in caries management, which can positively impact the quality of patient care.
通过手术治疗来教授龋损管理需要具有高度逼真解剖细节的牙齿模型以及可使用国际龋病检测与评估系统(ICDAS)进行评估的龋损。本研究旨在开发并评估一种新的3D打印牙齿模型,用于临床前实践教育中的ICDAS评估和龋损去除。
设计了具有不同牙釉质、牙本质和龋损层的可打印牙齿,并由31名牙科学生进行测试。要求他们通过视觉和影像学评估模拟龋损的ICDAS严重程度,根据CariesCare 4D确定治疗策略,并基于五点李克特量表项目对模型进行定性评估。
关于龋损,其质地逼真,94%和97%的参与者认为颜色合适。90%的参与者认为该模型足以进行ICDAS视觉评估。74%的学生认为硬度合适。关于牙釉质和牙本质之间颜色差异以及明显的硬度差异,参与者的意见不一,同意比例分别为61%和55%。所有参与者都认为这些3D打印模型能很好地模拟龋齿,适用于实践操作牙科课程,且学习效果优于标准模型。
目前的工作表明,快速成型为能够支持手术技能和术前技能的定制教育模型铺平了道路。3D打印通过缩小临床前培训与龋病管理临床实际之间的差距,开辟了新的机会,这可以对患者护理质量产生积极影响。