Consultant Chest Physician, Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Jindal Clinics, Chandigarh; Corresponding Author.
Consultant Chest Physician, Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Chest Research and Training (CREST), Pune, Maharashtra.
J Assoc Physicians India. 2023 Jun;71(6):11-12. doi: 10.5005/japi-11001-0273.
The use of nebulizers is an important and useful method for delivering drugs to the lungs in patients with various airway and lung parenchymal disorders. They are primarily used in patients with acute symptoms and in a selected group of patients for maintenance treatment. Its use has increased, especially during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. To ensure the appropriate use of nebulizers by primary care physicians and to guide them, we aimed to develop a simple nebulizer use score.
An expert working group (EWG) of pulmonologists were formed who using a semi- Delphi method, developed a list of variables and a cut-off score to decide when to use nebulizers. We started with a total of 55 variables that were developed through an exhaustive review of the literature. These were further reduced to smaller numbers that had the maximum score as well as concordance with the EWG. The scores ranged from 1 to 10 (completely disagree to completely agree), and only those above 7.5 were selected.
A total of 8 variables with the highest scores were selected (Table 1), which had a total maximum score of 40. A score of <15 was suggested to indicate no use of nebulizer and >20 to suggest definite use of nebulizer. A score between 15 and 20 was suggested for physician judgment. A separate table of 12 conditions was made where the use of nebulizers was mandatory.
This first-of-its-kind nebulizer score can be used by primary care physicians to decide which patients should be put on nebulizer treatment.
雾化器的使用是向患有各种气道和肺实质疾病的患者肺部输送药物的重要且有用的方法。它们主要用于有急性症状的患者和一组选定的维持治疗患者。其使用量有所增加,尤其是在 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行期间。为了确保初级保健医生正确使用雾化器并为他们提供指导,我们旨在制定一个简单的雾化器使用评分。
成立了一个由肺病专家组成的专家工作组(EWG),他们使用半 Delphi 方法制定了一系列变量和截止分数,以决定何时使用雾化器。我们从总共 55 个变量开始,这些变量是通过对文献的详尽回顾开发的。这些变量进一步减少到数量较少的变量,这些变量的分数最高,并且与 EWG 一致。分数范围为 1 到 10(完全不同意到完全同意),只有分数高于 7.5 的才会被选中。
共选择了 8 个得分最高的变量(表 1),总分为 40 分。建议得分 <15 表示不使用雾化器,得分 >20 表示肯定使用雾化器。得分在 15 到 20 之间的建议由医生判断。还制作了一个单独的包含 12 种情况的表格,其中使用雾化器是强制性的。
这是第一个此类雾化器评分,可以由初级保健医生用来决定哪些患者应该接受雾化器治疗。