Al-Wathinani Ahmed M, Barten Dennis G, Alsahli Hind, Alhamid Anfal, Alghamdi Waad, Alqahtani Wadha, Alghamdi Raghad, Aljuaid Mohammad, Albaqami Nawaf A, Goniewicz Krzysztof
Department of Emergency Medical Services, Prince Sultan bin Abdulaziz College for Emergency Medical Services, King Saud University, Riyadh 11451, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Emergency Medicine, VieCuri Medical Center, 5912 BL Venlo, The Netherlands.
Healthcare (Basel). 2023 Jun 15;11(12):1756. doi: 10.3390/healthcare11121756.
Healthcare providers in prehospital care and emergency departments are often at the frontline of medical crises, facing a range of ethical dilemmas, particularly when it comes to patients refusing treatment. This study aimed to delve into the attitudes of these providers toward treatment refusal, unearthing the strategies they employ in navigating such challenging situations while actively working in prehospital emergency health services. Our findings showed that, as the participants' age and experience increased, so did their inclination to respect patient autonomy and avoid persuading them to change their decision about treatment. It was noted that doctors, paramedics, and emergency medical technicians demonstrated a deeper understanding of patients' rights than other medical specialists. However, even with this understanding, the prioritization of patients' rights tended to diminish in life-threatening situations, giving rise to ethical dilemmas. This underlines the complexity of balancing the healthcare professionals' responsibilities and the patients' autonomy, which can generate ethically challenging scenarios for those working in emergency healthcare. By investigating these attitudes and experiences, this study seeks to foster a more profound understanding of the ethical quandaries faced by emergency healthcare providers. Our ultimate aim is to contribute to the development of effective strategies that support both patients and professionals in managing these tough circumstances.
院前护理和急诊科的医疗服务提供者常常处于医疗危机的第一线,面临一系列伦理困境,尤其是在患者拒绝治疗的情况下。本研究旨在深入探究这些医疗服务提供者对治疗拒绝的态度,揭示他们在院前紧急医疗服务中积极应对此类具有挑战性情况时所采用的策略。我们的研究结果表明,随着参与者年龄和经验的增加,他们尊重患者自主权并避免劝说患者改变治疗决定的倾向也随之增加。值得注意的是,医生、护理人员和急救医疗技术人员比其他医学专家对患者权利有更深刻的理解。然而,即便有这种理解,在危及生命的情况下,患者权利的优先级往往会降低,从而引发伦理困境。这凸显了平衡医疗专业人员的责任与患者自主权的复杂性,这可能给从事紧急医疗保健工作的人员带来伦理上具有挑战性的情形。通过调查这些态度和经历,本研究旨在促进对紧急医疗保健提供者所面临的伦理困境有更深刻的理解。我们的最终目标是为制定有效的策略做出贡献,以支持患者和专业人员应对这些艰难情况。