Willmer Felix, Reuter Claire, Pramsohler Stephan, Faulhaber Martin, Burkhardt Anja, Netzer Nikolaus
Hermann-Buhl-Institute for Hypoxia and Sleep Medicine Research, 83661 Lenggries, Germany.
Department of Sport Science, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
Life (Basel). 2023 Jun 19;13(6):1414. doi: 10.3390/life13061414.
Athletes often experience poor sleep quality due to stress, altitude exposure, travel across different time zones, and pre-competition nervousness. Coaches use daytime naps to counteract the negative effects of fragmented nighttime sleep. Napping before competitions has also been used to enhance performance in athletes without sleep problems, with mixed results in previous studies, particularly for endurance performance. Thus, we investigated the effects of napping after partial sleep deprivation (PSD) on endurance performance and wakefulness in athletes. We recruited 12 healthy and trained participants (seven female and five male) for a randomized crossover study design. The participants underwent two test sessions: a five-hour night of sleep without a nap (noNap) and a five-hour night of sleep with a 30-min nap opportunity (Nap30). Participants recorded their sleep-wake rhythm one week before and during the study using the Consensus Sleep Diary-Core and the Morningness-Eveningness Questionnaire to examine their circadian rhythm type. We quantified PSD and the nap with pupillography (pupil unrest index, PUI), a subjective level of sleepiness questionnaire (Karolinska Sleepiness Scale, KSS), and polysomnography. After each night, participants performed a maximal cycling ergometry test to determine time to exhaustion (TTE) and maximal oxygen uptake (VO ). Participants had an average sleep duration of 7.2 ± 0.7 h and were identified as moderately morning types ( = 5), neither type ( = 5), and moderately evening types ( = 2). There was a significant difference in both sleepiness parameters between the two conditions, with the PUI ( = 0.015) and KSS ( ≤ 0.01) significantly decreased at 5 h and nap compared with only 5 h of sleep. The PUI ( ≤ 0.01) and KSS ( ≤ 0.01) decreased significantly from before to after the nap. However, there was no significant difference in physical exercise test results between the conditions for TTE ( = 0.367) or VO ( = 0.308). Our results suggest that napping after light PSD does not significantly influence endurance performance. We conclude that aerobic performance is a multidimensional construct, and napping after PSD may not enhance it. However, napping is an effective method to increase wakefulness and vigilance, which can be beneficial for sports competitions.
运动员常常因压力、高原环境、跨时区旅行以及赛前紧张情绪而睡眠质量不佳。教练会利用白天小睡来抵消夜间碎片化睡眠的负面影响。在没有睡眠问题的运动员中,赛前小睡也被用于提高运动表现,然而此前的研究结果不一,尤其是在耐力表现方面。因此,我们研究了部分睡眠剥夺(PSD)后小睡对运动员耐力表现和清醒程度的影响。我们招募了12名健康且经过训练的参与者(7名女性和5名男性)进行随机交叉研究设计。参与者经历了两个测试阶段:一个五小时的夜间睡眠且无小睡(无小睡组)和一个五小时的夜间睡眠并有30分钟小睡机会(30分钟小睡组)。参与者在研究前一周以及研究期间使用《共识睡眠日记 - 核心版》和《晨型 - 夜型问卷》记录他们的睡眠 - 清醒节律,以检查他们的昼夜节律类型。我们通过瞳孔测量法(瞳孔不安指数,PUI)、主观嗜睡程度问卷(卡罗林斯卡嗜睡量表,KSS)和多导睡眠图来量化PSD和小睡情况。每个夜晚过后,参与者进行一次最大骑行测力计测试,以确定疲劳时间(TTE)和最大摄氧量(VO)。参与者的平均睡眠时间为7.2±0.7小时,被确定为中度晨型(n = 5)、非此非彼型(n = 5)和中度夜型(n = 2)。两种情况下的嗜睡参数均存在显著差异,与仅五小时睡眠相比,在五小时睡眠且小睡时PUI(P = 0.015)和KSS(P≤0.01)显著降低。小睡前后PUI(P≤0.01)和KSS(P≤0.01)显著下降。然而,在TTE(P = 0.367)或VO(P = 0.308)的体能测试结果方面,两种情况之间没有显著差异。我们的结果表明,轻度PSD后小睡对耐力表现没有显著影响。我们得出结论,有氧表现是一个多维度的概念,PSD后小睡可能无法提升它。然而,小睡是增加清醒程度和警觉性的有效方法,这对体育比赛可能有益。