Departamento de Fonoaudiologia, Faculdade de Filosofia e Ciências, Universidade Estadual Paulista "Júlio de Mesquita Filho" - UNESP - Marília (SP), Brasil.
Departamento de Fonoaudiologia, Universidade do Unoeste Paulista - UNOESTE - Presidente Prudente (SP), Brasil.
Codas. 2023 Jun 26;35(3):e20210280. doi: 10.1590/2317-1782/20232021280pt. eCollection 2023.
To compare the results of the non-linear acoustic analysis of elderly male and female voices, speakers of Brazilian Portuguese.
Recordings of 14 men and 15 women were used. The voices were consensually judged to be vocally healthy by three trained speech therapists. The non-linear acoustic analysis was performed by the Phase Space Reconstruction (PSR) analysis using the Voice Analysis program.
A significant difference was observed in the parameter irregularity (p = 0.001) and spacing (p = 0.005), with worse results for the male group. While 93% of male voices presented degrees 2 or 3 of irregularity, these degrees were observed in 53% of female voices. In 78.6% of male voices, medium to large spacing was observed, a fact observed only in 26.7% of women.
The results of the non-linear analysis, through the Phase Space Reconstruction, using the CIS Protocol, in the voices of the elderly, showed the best result in terms of the number of curves (four or more). Regarding the irregularity of the tracing, in men, the majority presented grades 2 and 3 and in women, half presented grade 1. Regarding the spacing, 78.6% of the male voices had medium to large spacing, a fact observed only in 26.7% of women.There was a difference between the sexes in the vocal findings of the elderly by the CIS protocol with the PSR, pointing out worse results irregularity and spacing in the male population, which suggests greater vocal aperiodicity in elderly men.
比较巴西老年男性和女性语音的非线性声学分析结果。
使用了 14 名男性和 15 名女性的录音。三位经过培训的语音治疗师一致认为这些声音是声带健康的。非线性声学分析是通过相位空间重建(PSR)分析,使用语音分析程序进行的。
在不规则性(p=0.001)和间距(p=0.005)参数方面观察到显著差异,男性组的结果更差。虽然 93%的男性声音呈现 2 级或 3 级不规则性,但在 53%的女性声音中观察到这些等级。在 78.6%的男性声音中观察到中等至较大的间距,而这一事实仅在 26.7%的女性中观察到。
通过相位空间重建使用 CIS 协议进行的非线性分析结果显示,在老年人的声音中,曲线数量(四个或更多)的结果最佳。关于跟踪的不规则性,在男性中,大多数呈现 2 级和 3 级,而在女性中,一半呈现 1 级。关于间距,78.6%的男性声音具有中等至较大的间距,这一事实仅在 26.7%的女性中观察到。CIS 协议与 PSR 对老年人的嗓音发现存在性别差异,指出男性人群的不规则性和间距较差,这表明老年男性的声带非周期性更大。