Gee J Michael, Wang Xiuyuan, Dogra Siddhant, Veraart Jelle, Ishida Koto, Dehkharghani Seena
medRxiv. 2023 Jun 3:2023.05.29.23290700. doi: 10.1101/2023.05.29.23290700.
Cerebral microangiopathy often manifests as white matter hyperintensities (WMH) on T2-weighted MR images and is associated with elevated stroke risk. Large vessel steno-occlusive disease (SOD) is also independently associated with stroke risk, however, the interaction of microangiopathy and SOD is not well understood. Cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) describes the capacity of cerebral circulation to adapt to changes in perfusion pressure and neurovascular demand, and its impairment portends future infarctions. CVR can be measured with blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) imaging following acetazolamide stimulus (ACZ-BOLD). We studied CVR differences between WMH and normal-appearing white matter (NAWM) in patients with chronic SOD, hypothesizing additive influences upon CVR measured by novel, fully dynamic CVR maxima ( ).
A cross sectional study was conducted to measure per-voxel, per-TR maximal CVR ( ) using a custom computational pipeline in 23 subjects with angiographically-proven unilateral SOD. WMH and NAWM masks were applied to maps. White matter was subclassified with respect to the SOD-affected hemisphere, including: i. contralateral NAWM; ii. contralateral WMH iii. ipsilateral NAWM; iv. ipsilateral WMH. was compared between these groups with a Kruskal-Wallis test followed by a Dunn-Sidak post-hoc test for multiple comparisons.
19 subjects (age 50±12 years, 53% female) undergoing 25 examinations met criteria. WMH volume was asymmetric in 16/19 subjects with 13/16 exhibiting higher volumes ipsilateral to SOD. Pairwise comparisons of between groups was significant with ipsilateral WMH lower than contralateral NAWM (p=0.015) and contralateral WMH (p=0.003) when comparing in-subject medians and lower than all groups when comparing pooled voxelwise values across all subjects (p<0.0001). No significant relationship between WMH lesion size and was detected.
Our results suggest additive effects of microvascular and macrovascular disease upon white matter CVR, but with greater overall effects relating to macrovascular SOD than to apparent microangiopathy. Dynamic ACZ-BOLD presents a promising path towards a quantitative stroke risk imaging biomarker.
Cerebral white matter (WM) microangiopathy manifests as sporadic or sometimes confluent high intensity lesions in MR imaging with T2-weighting, and bears known associations with stroke, cognitive disability, depression and other neurological disorders . Deep white matter is particularly susceptible to ischemic injury owing to the deprivation of collateral flow between penetrating arterial territories, and hence deep white matter hyperintensities (WMH) may portend future infarctions . The pathophysiology of WMH is variable but commonly includes a cascade of microvascular lipohyalinosis and atherosclerosis together with impaired vascular endothelial and neurogliovascular integrity, leading to blood brain barrier dysfunction, interstitial fluid accumulation, and eventually tissue damage . Independent of the microcirculation, cervical and intracranial large vessel steno-occlusive disease (SOD) often results from atheromatous disease and is associated with increased risk of stroke owing to thromboembolic phenomena, hypoperfusion, or combinations thereof . White matter disease is more common in the affected hemisphere of patients with asymmetric or unilateral SOD, producing both macroscopic WMH detectable by routine structural MRI, as well as microstructural changes and altered structural connectivity detected by advanced diffusion microstructural imaging . An improved understanding of the interaction of microvascular disease (i.e., WMH) and macrovascular steno-occlusion could better inform stroke risk stratification and guide treatment strategies when coexistent. Cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) is an autoregulatory adaptation characterized by the capacity of the cerebral circulation to respond to physiological or pharmacological vasodilatory stimuli . CVR may be heterogeneous and varies across tissue type and pathological states . Alterations in CVR are associated with elevated stroke risk in SOD patients, although white matter CVR, and in particular the CVR profiles of WMH, are only sparsely studied and not fully understood . We have previously employed blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) imaging following a hemodynamic stimulus with acetazolamide (ACZ) in order to measure CVR (i.e. ACZ-BOLD) . Despite the emergence of ACZ-BOLD as a technique for clinical and experimental use, poor signal-to-noise characteristics of the BOLD effect have generally limited its interpretation to coarse, time-averaged assessment of the terminal ACZ response at arbitrarily prescribed delays following ACZ administration (e.g. 10-20 minutes) . More recently, we have introduced a dedicated computational pipeline to overcome historically intractable signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) limitations of BOLD, enabling fully dynamic characterization of the cerebrovascular response, including identification of previously unreported, unsustained or transient CVR maxima ( ) following hemodynamic provocation . In this study, we compared such dynamic interrogation of true CVR maxima between WMH and normal appearing white matter (NAWM) among patients with chronic, unilateral SOD in order to quantify their interaction and to assess the hypothesized additive effects of angiographically-evident macrovascular stenoses when intersecting microangiopathic WMH.
脑微血管病变在T2加权磁共振图像上常表现为白质高信号(WMH),并与中风风险升高相关。大血管狭窄闭塞性疾病(SOD)也与中风风险独立相关,然而,微血管病变与SOD之间的相互作用尚不清楚。脑血管反应性(CVR)描述了脑循环适应灌注压力和神经血管需求变化的能力,其受损预示着未来梗死。CVR可通过乙酰唑胺刺激后的血氧水平依赖(BOLD)成像(ACZ - BOLD)进行测量。我们研究了慢性SOD患者中WMH与正常白质(NAWM)之间的CVR差异,假设通过新的、完全动态的CVR最大值( )测量,两者对CVR有叠加影响。
进行了一项横断面研究,使用定制的计算流程,在23例经血管造影证实为单侧SOD的受试者中测量每个体素、每个重复时间(TR)的最大CVR( )。将WMH和NAWM掩码应用于 图。白质根据受SOD影响的半球进行亚分类,包括:i. 对侧NAWM;ii. 对侧WMH;iii. 同侧NAWM;iv. 同侧WMH。通过Kruskal - Wallis检验比较这些组之间的 ,随后进行Dunn - Sidak事后检验进行多重比较。
19例受试者(年龄50±12岁,53%为女性)接受了25次检查,符合标准。16/19例受试者的WMH体积不对称,其中13/16例在SOD同侧的WMH体积更高。组间 的成对比较具有显著性,同侧WMH低于对侧NAWM(p = 0.015)和对侧WMH(p = 0.003)(比较受试者内中位数时),并且在比较所有受试者的合并体素值时低于所有组(p < 0.0001)。未检测到WMH病变大小与 之间的显著关系。
我们的结果表明微血管和大血管疾病对白质CVR有叠加作用,但与大血管SOD相关的总体影响大于明显的微血管病变。动态ACZ - BOLD为定量中风风险成像生物标志物提供了一条有前景的途径。
脑白质(WM)微血管病变在T2加权磁共振成像中表现为散在或有时融合的高强度病变,并且与中风、认知障碍、抑郁和其他神经系统疾病相关 。深部白质由于穿通动脉区域之间侧支血流的缺乏,特别容易受到缺血性损伤,因此深部白质高信号(WMH)可能预示着未来梗死 。WMH的病理生理学是可变的,但通常包括一系列微血管脂肪透明变性和动脉粥样硬化,以及血管内皮和神经胶质血管完整性受损,导致血脑屏障功能障碍、间质液积聚,最终导致组织损伤 。独立于微循环,颈内和颅内大血管狭窄闭塞性疾病(SOD)通常由动脉粥样硬化疾病引起,并且由于血栓栓塞现象、低灌注或两者的组合,与中风风险增加相关 。白质疾病在不对称或单侧SOD患者的受影响半球中更常见,产生常规结构MRI可检测到的宏观WMH,以及先进扩散微观成像检测到的微观结构变化和结构连接改变 。更好地理解微血管疾病(即WMH)和大血管狭窄闭塞之间的相互作用,可以在两者共存时更好地为中风风险分层提供信息并指导治疗策略。脑血管反应性(CVR)是一种自动调节适应,其特征是脑循环对生理或药理血管舒张刺激的反应能力 。CVR可能是异质性的,并且在不同组织类型和病理状态下有所不同 。CVR改变与SOD患者中风风险升高相关,尽管白质CVR,特别是WMH的CVR特征,研究较少且尚未完全理解 。我们之前采用乙酰唑胺(ACZ)进行血流动力学刺激后的血氧水平依赖(BOLD)成像来测量CVR(即ACZ - BOLD) 。尽管ACZ - BOLD作为一种临床和实验技术已经出现,但BOLD效应的低信噪比特性通常将其解释限制为在ACZ给药后任意规定延迟(例如10 - 20分钟)对最终ACZ反应的粗略、时间平均评估 。最近我们引入了一种专用的计算流程来克服BOLD历史上难以处理的信噪比(SNR)限制,从而能够对脑血管反应进行完全动态表征,包括识别血流动力学激发后先前未报告的、未持续或短暂的CVR最大值( ) 。在本研究中,我们比较了慢性单侧SOD患者中WMH与正常白质(NAWM)之间这种真正CVR最大值的动态询问,以量化它们的相互作用,并评估血管造影显示的大血管狭窄与微血管病变WMH相交时假设的叠加效应。