Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Department of Neurology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, U.S.A.
Westmead Comprehensive Epilepsy Unit, Westmead Hospital, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
J Clin Neurophysiol. 2023 Jul 1;40(5):434-442. doi: 10.1097/WNP.0000000000000897. Epub 2021 Sep 27.
Lateralized rhythmic delta activity (LRDA) is highly associated with seizures but generalized rhythmic delta activity (GRDA; symmetric by definition) has no known seizure association. A subset of LRDA includes patterns that are "bilateral asymmetric LRDA" (LRDA-ba), falling between purely unilateral LRDA and GRDA. The significance of this finding has not been previously addressed.
Clinical, EEG, and imaging findings were reviewed in all patients with >6 hours of continuous EEG and LRDA-ba between 2014 and 2019. They were compared with a control group of patients with GRDA, matched 1:1 for prevalence, duration, and frequency of the predominant rhythmic pattern.
Two hundred fifty-eight patients with LRDA-ba and 258 matched controls with GRDA were identified. Statistically significant findings included that patients with LRDA-ba were more likely to have presented with an ischemic stroke (LRDA-ba 12.4% vs. GRDA 3.9%) or subdural hemorrhage (8.9% vs. 4.3%); those with GRDA were more likely to have a metabolic encephalopathy (GRDA 10.5% vs. LRDA-ba 3.5%) or "altered mental state" without clear etiology (12.5% vs. 4.3%). Patients with LRDA-ba were significantly more likely to have a background EEG asymmetry (LRDA-ba 62.0% vs. GRDA 25.6%) or focal (arrhythmic) slowing (40.3% vs. 15.5%), and acute (65.5% vs. 46.1%) or focal (49.6% vs. 28.3%) abnormalities on computed tomography scan. Patients with LRDA-ba were more likely to have focal sporadic epileptiform discharges (95.4% vs. 37.9%), lateralized periodic discharges (32.2% vs. 5.0%), and focal electrographic seizures (33.3% vs. 11.2%); however, patients with LRDA-ba alone (i.e., without sporadic epileptiform discharges or PDs) showed only a trend toward increased seizures (17.3%) compared with a matched group of patients with GRDA alone (9.9%, P = 0.08).
Patients with LRDA-ba had a higher proportion of acute focal abnormalities compared with a matched group of patients with GRDA. The LRDA-ba was associated with additional evidence of focal cortical excitability on EEG (sporadic epileptiform discharges and lateralized periodic discharges) and seizures but with only a trend toward increased seizures when other signs of focal excitability were absent.
局灶性节律性δ活动(LRDA)与癫痫发作高度相关,但广义节律性δ活动(GRDA;根据定义对称)与癫痫发作无关。LRDA 的一个子集包括“双侧不对称 LRDA”(LRDA-ba),介于纯粹单侧 LRDA 和 GRDA 之间。这一发现的意义尚未得到先前的探讨。
对 2014 年至 2019 年间连续进行>6 小时 EEG 检查并出现 LRDA-ba 的所有患者的临床、脑电图和影像学表现进行了回顾性分析。将其与具有 GRDA 的对照组患者进行比较,对照组在优势节律模式的流行率、持续时间和频率上进行了 1:1 匹配。
共确定了 258 例出现 LRDA-ba 的患者和 258 例匹配的具有 GRDA 的对照组患者。具有统计学意义的发现包括,出现 LRDA-ba 的患者更可能出现缺血性中风(LRDA-ba 为 12.4%,GRDA 为 3.9%)或硬膜下血肿(LRDA-ba 为 8.9%,GRDA 为 4.3%);GRDA 患者更可能出现代谢性脑病(GRDA 为 10.5%,LRDA-ba 为 3.5%)或无明确病因的“精神状态改变”(GRDA 为 12.5%,LRDA-ba 为 4.3%)。出现 LRDA-ba 的患者更可能出现背景 EEG 不对称(LRDA-ba 为 62.0%,GRDA 为 25.6%)或局灶性(节律性)减慢(LRDA-ba 为 40.3%,GRDA 为 15.5%),更可能出现急性(LRDA-ba 为 65.5%,GRDA 为 46.1%)或局灶性(LRDA-ba 为 49.6%,GRDA 为 28.3%)计算机断层扫描异常。出现 LRDA-ba 的患者更可能出现局灶性散发性癫痫样放电(LRDA-ba 为 95.4%,GRDA 为 37.9%)、局灶性周期性放电(LRDA-ba 为 32.2%,GRDA 为 5.0%)和局灶性脑电图癫痫发作(LRDA-ba 为 33.3%,GRDA 为 11.2%);然而,出现 LRDA-ba 但无散发性癫痫样放电或 PDs 的患者(LRDA-ba 为 17.3%)与出现 GRDA 但无散发性癫痫样放电或 PDs 的患者(GRDA 为 9.9%)相比,癫痫发作的比例仅呈增加趋势(P=0.08)。
与匹配的 GRDA 患者相比,出现 LRDA-ba 的患者更可能出现急性局灶性异常。LRDA-ba 与 EEG 上局灶性皮质兴奋性的额外证据相关(散发性癫痫样放电和局灶性周期性放电)和癫痫发作,但当其他局灶性兴奋性迹象不存在时,仅呈癫痫发作增加的趋势。