Division of Pediatric Endocrinology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Medicine, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA.
Division of Endocrinology and Diabetes, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
J Genet Couns. 2023 Oct;32(5):937-941. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1649. Epub 2023 Jul 4.
Noninvasive prenatal screening (NIPS) with predicted fetal sex chromosomes included in the results has become increasingly available for pregnant individuals. Predicted fetal sex chromosome results from NIPS are interpreted so as to equate sex chromosomes with sex and gender. As pediatric endocrinologists, we worry about how this use of NIPS harmfully reinforces sex and gender binaries and sets potentially inaccurate assumptions about what the identified chromosomes mean. We use a hypothetical case based on our clinical experience in which the NIPS report of fetal sex does not conform to expectations at birth to highlight ethical concerns surrounding this practice. The use of NIPS for fetal sex chromosome prediction has the potential to perpetuate stigma and bring psychological harm to parents and their future children, particularly those who are intersex, transgender, and gender diverse. The medical community should adopt an approach to the use of NIPS for fetal sex chromosome prediction that recognizes the spectrums of sex and gender to avoid reproducing stigma towards sex- and gender-diverse individuals and associated harms.
包含预测胎儿性染色体结果的无创产前筛查 (NIPS) 越来越多地应用于孕妇。NIPS 预测胎儿性染色体的结果被解释为将性染色体等同于性别和性别认同。作为儿科内分泌学家,我们担心这种使用 NIPS 如何有害地强化性别二元论,并对所识别的染色体意味着什么做出潜在不准确的假设。我们使用基于我们临床经验的假设案例,其中 NIPS 报告的胎儿性别与出生时的预期不符,以突出围绕这种做法的伦理问题。使用 NIPS 预测胎儿性染色体可能会使父母及其未来的孩子(尤其是那些具有间性、跨性别和性别多样化的孩子)受到污名化和心理伤害。医学界应该采取一种使用 NIPS 预测胎儿性染色体的方法,该方法认识到性和性别认同的多样性,以避免对性别和性别多样化的个体及其相关伤害产生污名化。